Proposition 4, p. 1004 — under A4 and A5 the retailer's optimal effort under returns alone is strictly increasing in the return credit b
ProvedChannelRebate.ReturnsEffort.proposition4_returns_increase_effortLet and (Assumption A1). Let demand be , where is the retailer's sales effort and has a density with for all (Assumption A4). Let the effort cost be strictly convex and strictly increasing on with (Assumption A5), and differentiable on . Under a return credit the retailer chooses and to maximize
Let , let be an optimal pair under and an optimal pair under , and suppose . Then
That is, the retailer's optimal effort under returns alone is strictly increasing in the return credit, the paper's . This reverses the conventional view that returns weaken a retailer's incentive for sales effort: for a fixed order quantity a larger credit lowers the marginal value of effort, but once the order quantity is re-optimized together with the effort, a larger credit raises effort.
Formalization Note The paper states and its proof establishes strict monotonicity, which is what is formalized; a derivative would need to be differentiable, which A5 does not provide. Differentiability of on is added because the paper uses in and in the first-order condition. Effort at the smaller credit is assumed positive, following the paper's restriction to strictly positive effort (p. 1000). Optimal pairs are maximizers over , ; their existence is a hypothesis, as on p. 999.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ChannelRebate_ReturnsEffort_Setting
namespace ChannelRebate.ReturnsEffort
/-- Taylor (2002), Proposition 4, p. 1004 (proof p. 1006): under A4 and A5, the retailer's
optimal effort under returns alone is strictly increasing in the return credit. If
`s ≤ b₂ < b₁ < w` and `(Q₁, e₁)`, `(Q₂, e₂)` are optimal order–effort pairs under the credits
`b₁`, `b₂` with `e₂ > 0`, then `e₂ < e₁`. -/
theorem proposition4_returns_increase_effort (p c s w : ℝ) (hc : 0 < c) (hcw : c < w)
(hwp : w < p) (hsc : s < c) (D : Demand) (V : EffortCost) (V' : ℝ → ℝ)
(hV' : ∀ e > 0, HasDerivAt V.V (V' e) e) (b₁ b₂ : ℝ) (hs : s ≤ b₂) (h12 : b₂ < b₁)
(hw : b₁ < w) (Q₁ e₁ Q₂ e₂ : ℝ) (h₁ : IsOptimalPair (returnsProfit p w b₁ D V) Q₁ e₁)
(h₂ : IsOptimalPair (returnsProfit p w b₂ D V) Q₂ e₂) (he₂ : 0 < e₂) :
e₂ < e₁ := by sorry
end ChannelRebate.ReturnsEffort
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.