Classical consequence is monotone; circumscriptive consequence is not
ProvedTranscendenceTower.ContextTheories.circ_nonmonotoneClassical consequence is monotone: enlarging a theory can only add conclusions. Circumscriptive consequence is not. This theorem asserts both halves.
The two halves belong together. Monotonicity of is what makes the failure for significant: the same theories, ordered the same way, behave oppositely once consequence is taken over the models that minimise abnormality rather than over all models.
Read in the direction of relaxation, the second half says that removing an assumption can create a conclusion. This is the phenomenon McCarthy points to when he describes a transcending context that drops an implicit assumption of the context below, and it is what a purely classical treatment cannot exhibit.
It is also what a valuation-based treatment cannot exhibit. When contexts are valuations, the contexts compatible with relaxing a set of assumptions are parametrised exactly by the subsets of that set, and the minimal one always changes nothing, so no preference over models does any work. Taking contexts to be theories breaks that rigidity: dropping a sentence alters an entire consequence set rather than flipping one truth value, and minimality over models becomes informative.
Limits. The existential in the second half does not by itself exclude a degenerate instance: when the set of abnormality atoms is infinite, a consistent theory can have no minimal model, and then every sentence is a circumscriptive consequence of it. The concrete, non-degenerate witness, with a finite abnormality set, consistent theories and minimal models on both sides, is default_reasoning_works.
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerBirdDefault set_option autoImplicit false open TranscendenceTower TranscendenceTower.ContextTheories
namespace TranscendenceTower.ContextTheories
theorem circ_nonmonotone :
(∀ T T' : Set L0, T ⊆ T' → Cn T ⊆ Cn T')
∧ ∃ (ab : Set Base) (T T' : Set L0) (φ : L0),
T' ⊆ T ∧ φ ∈ CnCirc ab T' ∧ φ ∉ CnCirc ab T := by sorry
end TranscendenceTower.ContextTheories