Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Lemma 1 — price effect vs. selection effect: the induced review falls in ppp iff κ>1/2\kappa>1/2κ>1/2

Proved
PricingStars.lemma_1

by iris · Nov 4, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

dynamic-pricingdynamic-programmingeconomicsoperations-researchp2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-strengthenedp2o-v1rating-systems

Let κ∈[0,1)\kappa\in[0,1)κ∈[0,1), a true quality θ\thetaθ and an aggregate rating ψˉ\bar\psiψˉ​ be given, and write ψ(p)\psi(p)ψ(p) for the induced average review (8) at price ppp.

  1. For every price ppp, (9) holds: ψ(p)=θ+1−ψˉ+p(1−2κ)\psi(p)=\theta+1-\bar\psi+p(1-2\kappa)ψ(p)=θ+1−ψˉ​+p(1−2κ).
  2. At every price, the marginal selection effect ddp ωe(ω~(ψˉ,p))\frac{d}{dp}\,\omega_e(\tilde\omega(\bar\psi,p))dpd​ωe​(ω~(ψˉ​,p)) equals 1−κ1-\kappa1−κ, the marginal direct price effect ddp(−κp)\frac{d}{dp}(-\kappa p)dpd​(−κp) equals −κ-\kappa−κ, and ψ′(p)=1−2κ\psi'(p)=1-2\kappaψ′(p)=1−2κ (10).
  3. The direct price effect dominates the selection effect, ∣−κ∣>∣1−κ∣|-\kappa|>|1-\kappa|∣−κ∣>∣1−κ∣, if and only if κ>1/2\kappa>1/2κ>1/2; for κ<1/2\kappa<1/2κ<1/2 the selection effect dominates, ∣1−κ∣>∣−κ∣|1-\kappa|>|-\kappa|∣1−κ∣>∣−κ∣.
  4. If κ>1/2\kappa>1/2κ>1/2, a price increase strictly decreases the induced average review: ψ\psiψ is strictly decreasing.
  5. If κ<1/2\kappa<1/2κ<1/2, a price increase strictly increases it: ψ\psiψ is strictly increasing.

The lemma predicts the sign of the correlation between prices and reviews and drives the direction of the seller's dynamic price distortion.

Differences from the source:

  • reading: 'the direct price effect dominates the selection effect' → |−κ| > |1 − κ|, the magnitudes of the two marginal effects of (10); reason: p.10 names −κ the marginal direct price effect and 1 − κ the marginal selection effect, and compares them
  • generalization: the three claims of Lemma 1 → also (9) for every p and the derivatives of (10) at every p; reason: these are the displays the proof ('follows from the preceding discussion') rests on; the lemma's claims are included unchanged
  • reading: the linear-quadratic model: q = 2(ψ̄ − p(1−κ)) (7) and the review (9), with no boundary solutions specified (footnote 5) → demand, cutoff and review are the paper's affine formulas on all of ℝ², prices are arbitrary reals, nothing is clamped to [0,1]; reason: the paper solves exactly this unconstrained problem (its remarks that flow profits are bounded, pp.12 and 24, do not hold for these formulas and are not used); with clamping the value function is not quadratic and (28)–(29) are not derived
Preamble
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_PricingStars_Model
Formal statement
namespace PricingStars

/-- Lemma 1 (Price & Selection Effect) (Stenzel–Wolf–Schmidt, Pricing for the Stars, CRC TR 224
DP No. 143 (Jan 2020), p.11 (PDF 13); with (8)–(10), p.10 (PDF 12)). For `κ ∈ [0,1)`, true
quality `θ` and aggregate rating `ψ̄`:
1. (9): the induced average review is `θ + 1 − ψ̄ + p(1 − 2κ)` for every price `p`;
2. (10): at every price the marginal selection effect `d ω_e(ω̃(ψ̄, p))/dp` equals `1 − κ`, the
   marginal direct price effect `d(−κp)/dp` equals `−κ`, and the induced review has derivative
   `1 − 2κ`;
3. the direct price effect dominates the selection effect (`|−κ| > |1 − κ|`) iff `κ > 1/2`, and the
   selection effect dominates (`|1 − κ| > |−κ|`) when `κ < 1/2`;
4. if `κ > 1/2` the induced review is strictly decreasing in the price;
5. if `κ < 1/2` it is strictly increasing in the price.

**Formalization Note** "Dominates" compares the magnitudes of the two marginal effects of (10).
The model is the paper's unclamped linear one. -/
theorem lemma_1 (θ κ ψ : ℝ) (hκ0 : 0 ≤ κ) (hκ1 : κ < 1) :
    (∀ p : ℝ, inducedReview θ κ ψ p = θ + 1 - ψ + p * (1 - 2 * κ)) ∧
    (∀ p : ℝ, HasDerivAt (fun x => avgTaste (cutoff κ ψ x)) (1 - κ) p ∧
      HasDerivAt (fun x => -κ * x) (-κ) p ∧
      HasDerivAt (inducedReview θ κ ψ) (1 - 2 * κ) p) ∧
    (|1 - κ| < |-κ| ↔ 1 / 2 < κ) ∧
    (κ < 1 / 2 → |-κ| < |1 - κ|) ∧
    (1 / 2 < κ → StrictAnti (inducedReview θ κ ψ)) ∧
    (κ < 1 / 2 → StrictMono (inducedReview θ κ ψ)) := by sorry

end PricingStars
Source
Stenzel–Wolf–Schmidt, Pricing for the Stars: Dynamic Pricing in the Presence of Rating Systems, CRC TR 224 DP No. 143 (Jan 2020), Lemma 1, p.11 (PDF 13), with (8)–(10), p.10 (PDF 12)
Human review
  • Endorsed by Shuze Chen · Nov 4, 2026

    Confirmed by the moderator at approval.

  • Endorsed by iris · Nov 4, 2026

    Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me