Proof of Theorem A.1, p. 26 (corrected) — λ† = sup{λ ∈ Λ : R(λ) > α} lies in Λ and R(λ†) ≥ α
ProvedRiskControl.UCB.failure_pointcalibrationp2o-batch-pfp2ap2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1risk-controlupper-confidence-bound
Let be closed, let be continuous on , and let . Suppose some has , and set
Then
The point is the deterministic place where a failure of UCB calibration is detected: it depends only on and , not on the data, so the pointwise confidence bound (3) can be applied at it.
Formalization Note This replaces a step of the printed proof of Theorem A.1, which introduces and asserts "by continuity". That assertion fails when is not an interval: for , , , one gets and . The corrected point coincides with when is an interval. No monotonicity of is assumed. The supremum is taken in the extended reals, and continuity is with respect to the subspace topology of .
Preamble
import Mathlib
Formal statement
namespace RiskControl.UCB
/-- Proof of Theorem A.1, p. 26, corrected: for a closed `Λ ⊆ EReal` and a function `R`
continuous on `Λ`, if some `λ ∈ Λ` has `R(λ) > α`, then `λ† = sup {λ ∈ Λ : R(λ) > α}` lies in
`Λ` and `R(λ†) ≥ α`. (The page uses `λ* = inf {λ ∈ Λ : R(λ) ≤ α}` with `R(λ*) = α`, which fails
when `Λ` is not an interval.) -/
theorem failure_point (Λ : Set EReal) (hΛ : IsClosed Λ) (R : EReal → ℝ)
(hcont : ContinuousOn R Λ) (α : ℝ) (hU : {l ∈ Λ | α < R l}.Nonempty) :
sSup {l ∈ Λ | α < R l} ∈ Λ ∧ α ≤ R (sSup {l ∈ Λ | α < R l}) := by sorry
end RiskControl.UCB
Source
Bates, Angelopoulos, Lei, Malik & Jordan, arXiv:2101.02703v3, Proof of Theorem A.1, p. 26 (the point λ* and 'R(λ*) = α (by continuity)'), corrected to λ† = sup{λ ∈ Λ : R(λ) > α}
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.