A symmetric selected history can distinguish equal present records
ProvedAPFB07b.rate_is_held_on_realized_historyapfapf-referencesib-v44-2026-11
With A2/BW on finite histories, sum cost and admissibility under a supplied mirror permutation force mirrored realized records to agree. If mirror and next obey the displayed compatibility equation and a record changes over two steps, supplied state/readout/hold correspondence and later-record descent yield mirrored next states with equal present records but distinct physical classes.
Preamble
import Theorems.Thm_APFB07b_realized_fixed_by_cost_symmetry import Theorems.Thm_APFB07b_realized_has_no_rate_of_present_records import Theorems.Thm_APFB07b_realized_rate_not_forbidden import Mathlib.Algebra.BigOperators.Group.Finset.Basic import Mathlib.Data.Fintype.BigOperators set_option autoImplicit false universe uX uP uR namespace APFPaper5.K3 end APFPaper5.K3 open APFPaper5.K3
Formal statement
theorem APFB07b.rate_is_held_on_realized_history {Interface : Type*} {T : Type*} [Fintype T]
{X : Type uX} {Process : Type uP} {R : Type uR}
(originalAdmissible : Interface → (T → R) → Prop) (totalCost : Interface → (T → R) → ℝ)
(realized : Interface → (T → R))
(hA2 : APFB07a.A2Selection originalAdmissible totalCost realized)
(hBW : APFB07b.BWUniqueMinimum originalAdmissible totalCost) (sigma : T ≃ T) (next : T → T)
(hsigma : ∀ t : T, next (sigma (next t)) = sigma t)
(c : Interface → R → ℝ) (hsum : ∀ i r, totalCost i r = ∑ t, c i (r t))
(hundo : ∀ i r, originalAdmissible i r → originalAdmissible i (fun t => r (sigma t)))
(i : Interface) (profile : X → Process → Prop) (now : X → R) (D : X → X) (o : T → X)
(hrec : ∀ t : T, realized i t = now (o t)) (ho : ∀ t : T, o (next t) = D (o t))
(hfact : ∀ r : R, APFB01.Descends profile (fun x => now (D x) = r))
(t : T) (hmove : realized i (next (next t)) ≠ realized i t) :
now (o (sigma (next t))) = now (o (next t)) ∧
APFB01.physicalClass profile (o (sigma (next t))) ≠
APFB01.physicalClass profile (o (next t)) := by sorry
Source
Sib v44 Theorems/Thm_APFB07_realized_history_retraces.lean:99
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).