Example 3.3, p. 698 — F′(ξ(1,1)ᵀ) = P̃⁻¹ + 12νξ/(1 + νξ)³ [2 −1; −4 2] is not symmetric
ProvedBilinearGramian.Integrability.jacobian_not_symmLet be the data of Example 3.3, let solve (3.9) for every , and let . Let be real with and , and . Then is differentiable at with Jacobian matrix (entry equal to )
and this matrix is not symmetric.
Since the Jacobian of a gradient field is a Hessian, hence symmetric, this is the obstruction that rules out (3.8) for the example.
Formalization Note The paper writes the second term of as , computed through a Kronecker formula for that omits the minus sign forced by (3.9); with the sign restored, this matrix is the representation of , so plus it, as stated. This was checked numerically by central differences. The non-symmetry conclusion is the paper's. The derivative is the linear map .
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_BilinearGramian_Integrability_LinGramian import Definitions.Def_BilinearGramian_Integrability_Example33 open Matrix
namespace BilinearGramian.Integrability
/-- Example 3.3, p. 698 (Benner–Damm 2011): let `P̃(x)` solve (3.9) for the example data at
every `x`, and `F(x) = P̃(x)⁻¹ x`. At `x = ξ (1, 1)ᵀ` with `1 + νξ ≠ 0`, the Jacobian
matrix of `F` (entry `(i, k)` is `∂F_i/∂x_k`) is
`P̃(x)⁻¹ + 12νξ/(1 + νξ)³ [2 -1; -4 2]`, and for `νξ ≠ 0` it is not symmetric. -/
theorem jacobian_not_symm (ν ξ : ℝ) (hνξ0 : ν * ξ ≠ 0) (hνξ : 1 + ν * ξ ≠ 0)
(Pt : (Fin 2 → ℝ) → Matrix (Fin 2) (Fin 2) ℝ)
(hPt : ∀ x, IsLinGramian exA (fun _ : Fin 1 => exN ν) exB x (Pt x)) :
HasFDerivAt (fun y => (Pt y)⁻¹ *ᵥ y)
(Matrix.toLin' ((Pt (ξ • ![1, 1]))⁻¹ +
(12 * ν * ξ / (1 + ν * ξ) ^ 3) • !![2, -1; -4, 2])).toContinuousLinearMap
(ξ • ![1, 1]) ∧
¬ ((Pt (ξ • ![1, 1]))⁻¹ + (12 * ν * ξ / (1 + ν * ξ) ^ 3) • !![2, -1; -4, 2]).IsSymm := by sorry
end BilinearGramian.Integrability
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.