Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Nuclear traces of powers of Dwork's qqq-level operator are limits of finite cutoff traces

Proved
FiniteFields.Dwork.tracePower_dworkQFrobeniusNuclearOperator_tendsto

by Idealson · Oct 20, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

dwork-rationalityfredholm-determinantp-adic-analysisweil-conjectures

Let ppp be a prime and kkk a finite field of characteristic ppp, with q=∣k∣=paq=|k|=p^aq=∣k∣=pa elements, a=[k:Fp]a=[k:\mathbb F_p]a=[k:Fp​]. Write W(k)W(k)W(k) for the ring of ppp-typical Witt vectors of kkk, FFF for its Witt vector Frobenius, KKK for the completion of the fraction field of W(k)W(k)W(k) with respect to its ppp-adic valuation, and σ\sigmaσ for the continuous extension of FFF to KKK. Let L=K(ζ)L=K(\zeta)L=K(ζ) be the ppp-th cyclotomic extension of KKK, where ζ∈L\zeta\in Lζ∈L is a fixed primitive ppp-th root of unity, equipped with the spectral norm ∣⋅∣|\cdot|∣⋅∣ extending the absolute value of KKK. For x∈kx\in kx∈k, write x^∈L\hat x\in Lx^∈L for the image of the Teichmüller representative [x]∈W(k)[x]\in W(k)[x]∈W(k).

Let E(X)=exp⁡(−∑j≥0Xpj/pj)\mathbb E(X)=\exp\big(-\sum_{j\ge0}X^{p^j}/p^j\big)E(X)=exp(−∑j≥0​Xpj/pj) be the (inverse) Artin–Hasse exponential, a power series with ppp-integral rational coefficients, and let η∈L\eta\in Lη∈L be the unique element with ∣η∣≤∣ζ−1∣|\eta|\le|\zeta-1|∣η∣≤∣ζ−1∣, ∣η∣<1|\eta|<1∣η∣<1 and E(η)=ζ\mathbb E(\eta)=\zetaE(η)=ζ. Dwork's splitting series is θ(X)=E(ηX)=∑n≥0βnXn∈L[[X]]\theta(X)=\mathbb E(\eta X)=\sum_{n\ge0}\beta_nX^n\in L[[X]]θ(X)=E(ηX)=∑n≥0​βn​Xn∈L[[X]], and for x∈kx\in kx∈k the splitting value θ(x^)\theta(\hat x)θ(x^) is the sum ∑n≥0βnx^ n\sum_{n\ge0}\beta_n\hat x^{\,n}∑n≥0​βn​x^n in LLL.

Fix d≥0d\ge0d≥0, a polynomial f=∑ufuxu∈k[x1,…,xd]f=\sum_u f_u x^u\in k[x_1,\dots,x_d]f=∑u​fu​xu∈k[x1​,…,xd​] (monomials xux^uxu, u∈Ndu\in\mathbb N^du∈Nd), and a weight vector w=(w1,…,wd)w=(w_1,\dots,w_d)w=(w1​,…,wd​) of positive integers; the weight of uuu is ∣u∣w=∑iwiui|u|_w=\sum_i w_iu_i∣u∣w​=∑i​wi​ui​, and for N≥0N\ge0N≥0 the cutoff MN={u∈Nd:∣u∣w≤N}M_N=\{u\in\mathbb N^d:|u|_w\le N\}MN​={u∈Nd:∣u∣w​≤N} is finite. On the Banach algebra of series g=∑ucuxug=\sum_u c_ux^ug=∑u​cu​xu with coefficients cu∈Lc_u\in Lcu​∈L tending to 000, consider:

  1. Dwork's splitting product H(x)=∏u: fu≠0θ(f^u xu)H(x)=\prod_{u:\,f_u\ne0}\theta\big(\hat f_u\,x^u\big)H(x)=∏u:fu​=0​θ(f^​u​xu);
  2. the operator ψp(∑ucuxu)=∑ucpuxu\psi_p\big(\sum_u c_ux^u\big)=\sum_u c_{pu}x^uψp​(∑u​cu​xu)=∑u​cpu​xu;
  3. the ppp-level Dwork operator α(g)=σ~−1(ψp(H⋅g))\alpha(g)=\tilde\sigma^{-1}\big(\psi_p(H\cdot g)\big)α(g)=σ~−1(ψp​(H⋅g)), where σ~\tilde\sigmaσ~ is the Frobenius of LLL extending σ\sigmaσ and fixing ζ\zetaζ, applied coefficientwise, and the qqq-level operator αq=αa\alpha_q=\alpha^{a}αq​=αa (aaa-fold iterate).

Let A(u,v)A(u,v)A(u,v) be the coefficient of xux^uxu in αq(xv)\alpha_q(x^v)αq​(xv), and let AN=(A(u,v))u,v∈MNA_N=\big(A(u,v)\big)_{u,v\in M_N}AN​=(A(u,v))u,v∈MN​​ be the finite cutoff matrix. Let TTT be the nuclear operator attached to αq\alpha_qαq​: its kernel is the diagonally conjugated matrix A~(u,v)=γe(v)γ−e(u)A(u,v)\tilde A(u,v)=\gamma^{e(v)}\gamma^{-e(u)}A(u,v)A~(u,v)=γe(v)γ−e(u)A(u,v), where γ=ζ−1\gamma=\zeta-1γ=ζ−1 and e(u)∈Ne(u)\in\mathbb Ne(u)∈N is an explicit exponent depending on fff, www, ppp and ∣u∣w|u|_w∣u∣w​, and for s≥1s\ge1s≥1 the trace of its sss-th power is

Tr⁡(Ts)=lim⁡N→∞tr⁡(A~N s).\operatorname{Tr}(T^s)=\lim_{N\to\infty}\operatorname{tr}\big(\tilde A_N^{\,s}\big).Tr(Ts)=N→∞lim​tr(A~Ns​).

Then for every integer s≥1s\ge1s≥1, the finite traces of the unconjugated cutoff matrices converge to this nuclear trace:

lim⁡N→∞tr⁡(AN s)=Tr⁡(Ts).\lim_{N\to\infty}\operatorname{tr}\big(A_N^{\,s}\big)=\operatorname{Tr}(T^s).N→∞lim​tr(ANs​)=Tr(Ts).

This lets the trace formula and the Fredholm determinant computations of §2–§3 work directly with the literal matrix coefficients of αq=ψ∘H\alpha_q=\psi\circ Hαq​=ψ∘H, while the nuclear decay estimates are carried by the normalized kernel.

Formalization Note Tr⁡(Ts)\operatorname{Tr}(T^s)Tr(Ts) is defined with Lean's limUnder, so the theorem asserts in particular that the limit on the left exists. The polynomial fff is given as a finitely supported coefficient function on Nd\mathbb N^dNd, all monomials u∈Ndu\in\mathbb N^du∈Nd (including those with zero exponents) index the matrix, and sss ranges over positive integers (ℕ+). The exponent e(u)e(u)e(u) is dworkQDiagonalExponent, ⌊(3p∣u∣w−G)/(2G)⌋\lfloor(3p|u|_w-G)/(2G)\rfloor⌊(3p∣u∣w​−G)/(2G)⌋ with truncated subtraction, where GGG is an explicit positive integer depending on fff, www and qqq.

Preamble
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_FiniteFields_Dwork_NuclearOperator

open Filter Topology
open FiniteFields.Dwork
variable (k : Type*) (p : ℕ) [Fact p.Prime] [Field k] [CharP k p] [Finite k]
variable {d : ℕ} (w : PositiveMonomialWeight d)
Formal statement
theorem FiniteFields.Dwork.tracePower_dworkQFrobeniusNuclearOperator_tendsto (f : MonomialIndex d →₀ k)
    (power : ℕ+) :
    Tendsto (fun bound =>
        finiteKernelPowerTrace w (dworkQFrobeniusKernel k p w f) (power : ℕ) bound) atTop
      (nhds (NuclearOperator.tracePower w (dworkQFrobeniusNuclearOperator k p w f) power)) := by sorry
Source
B. Dwork, *On the rationality of the zeta function of an algebraic variety*, Amer. J. Math. 82 (1960), 631–648, §2 (the operator ψ∘H\psi\circ Hψ∘H, its matrix and the traces of its powers, Lemma 2 and formula (14)) and §3 (16)–(21) (Fredholm determinants as limits over finite cutoffs); auxiliary lemma in the formalization, with no direct counterpart in the paper, where traces are defined directly as sums of diagonal entries. Lean: ported from the `finite_fields` project (commit e8b5bf14), file `WeilConjectures/Dwork/DworkNuclearOperator/TracePowers.lean`, declaration `WeilConjectures.Dwork.tracePower_dworkQFrobeniusNuclearOperator_tendsto`

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me