Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Theorem V.3 (Synchronization condition I), corrected — Γmin⁡>Γcritical\Gamma_{\min}>\Gamma_{\mathrm{critical}}Γmin​>Γcritical​ gives phase cohesiveness and exponential frequency synchronization

Proved
NonuniformKuramoto.CondI.theorem_V_3

by mikedeng1 · Oct 7, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

kuramoto-modelp2o-batch-pfp2bp2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1phase-cohesivenesspower-networkssynchronization

Consider the non-uniform Kuramoto model (8),

Diθ˙i=ωi−∑j=1nPijsin⁡(θi−θj+φij),D_i\dot\theta_i=\omega_i-\sum_{j=1}^nP_{ij}\sin(\theta_i-\theta_j+\varphi_{ij}),Di​θ˙i​=ωi​−j=1∑n​Pij​sin(θi​−θj​+φij​),

with n≥2n\ge2n≥2 oscillators, Di>0D_i>0Di​>0, ωi∈R\omega_i\in\mathbb Rωi​∈R, a symmetric complete coupling graph (Pij=Pji>0P_{ij}=P_{ji}>0Pij​=Pji​>0 for i≠ji\ne ji=j), phase shifts φij∈[0,π/2[\varphi_{ij}\in[0,\pi/2[φij​∈[0,π/2[ for i≠ji\ne ji=j, and Pii=φii=0P_{ii}=\varphi_{ii}=0Pii​=φii​=0. Assume that the minimal lossless coupling of any oscillator to the network exceeds a critical value:

Γmin⁡:=nmin⁡i≠j{PijDicos⁡(φij)}>Γcritical:=1cos⁡(φmax⁡)(max⁡i≠j∣ωiDi−ωjDj∣+2max⁡i∑j=1nPijDisin⁡(φij)).(26)\Gamma_{\min}:=n\min_{i\neq j}\Big\{\frac{P_{ij}}{D_i}\cos(\varphi_{ij})\Big\}>\Gamma_{\mathrm{critical}}:=\frac{1}{\cos(\varphi_{\max})}\Big(\max_{i\neq j}\Big|\frac{\omega_i}{D_i}-\frac{\omega_j}{D_j}\Big|+2\max_{i}\sum_{j=1}^n\frac{P_{ij}}{D_i}\sin(\varphi_{ij})\Big).\qquad(26)Γmin​:=ni=jmin​{Di​Pij​​cos(φij​)}>Γcritical​:=cos(φmax​)1​(i=jmax​​Di​ωi​​−Dj​ωj​​​+2imax​j=1∑n​Di​Pij​​sin(φij​)).(26)

Let γmin⁡∈[0,π/2−φmax⁡[\gamma_{\min}\in[0,\pi/2-\varphi_{\max}[γmin​∈[0,π/2−φmax​[ and γmax⁡∈ ]π/2,π]\gamma_{\max}\in\,]\pi/2,\pi]γmax​∈]π/2,π] be the solutions of sin⁡(γmin⁡)=sin⁡(γmax⁡)=cos⁡(φmax⁡)Γcritical/Γmin⁡\sin(\gamma_{\min})=\sin(\gamma_{\max})=\cos(\varphi_{\max})\Gamma_{\mathrm{critical}}/\Gamma_{\min}sin(γmin​)=sin(γmax​)=cos(φmax​)Γcritical​/Γmin​. Then:

  1. Phase cohesiveness. Δˉ(γ)\bar\Delta(\gamma)Δˉ(γ) is positively invariant for every γ∈[γmin⁡,γmax⁡]\gamma\in[\gamma_{\min},\gamma_{\max}]γ∈[γmin​,γmax​]; and every solution with θ(0)∈Δ(γmax⁡)\theta(0)\in\Delta(\gamma_{\max})θ(0)∈Δ(γmax​) satisfies, for every γ∈ ]γmin⁡,γmax⁡]\gamma\in\,]\gamma_{\min},\gamma_{\max}]γ∈]γmin​,γmax​], θ(t)∈Δˉ(γ)\theta(t)\in\bar\Delta(\gamma)θ(t)∈Δˉ(γ) for all ttt beyond some T≥0T\ge0T≥0.
  2. Frequency synchronization. For every solution with θ(0)∈Δ(γmax⁡)\theta(0)\in\Delta(\gamma_{\max})θ(0)∈Δ(γmax​) there are θ˙∞\dot\theta_\inftyθ˙∞​, CCC and λ>0\lambda>0λ>0 with ∣θ˙i(t)−θ˙∞∣≤Ce−λt|\dot\theta_i(t)-\dot\theta_\infty|\le Ce^{-\lambda t}∣θ˙i​(t)−θ˙∞​∣≤Ce−λt for all t≥0t\ge0t≥0 and all iii; if moreover θ(0)∈Δ(π/2−φmax⁡)\theta(0)\in\Delta(\pi/2-\varphi_{\max})θ(0)∈Δ(π/2−φmax​), then θ˙∞∈[θ˙min⁡(0),θ˙max⁡(0)]\dot\theta_\infty\in[\dot\theta_{\min}(0),\dot\theta_{\max}(0)]θ˙∞​∈[θ˙min​(0),θ˙max​(0)].

This is the paper's main synchronization result for the non-uniform Kuramoto model (statements 1)–2) of Theorem III.2): an explicit algebraic test on the network parameters that guarantees phase cohesiveness and frequency synchronization, and hence transient stability of the associated power network.

Formalization Note Two clauses of the printed theorem are false as stated and are replaced by their corrected forms. (i) "Each trajectory starting in Δ(γmax⁡)\Delta(\gamma_{\max})Δ(γmax​) reaches Δˉ(γmin⁡)\bar\Delta(\gamma_{\min})Δˉ(γmin​)" holds only asymptotically: for n=2n=2n=2, φ≡0\varphi\equiv0φ≡0, D≡1D\equiv1D≡1, P12=P21=1P_{12}=P_{21}=1P12​=P21​=1, ω=(1,0)\omega=(1,0)ω=(1,0) one gets γmin⁡=π/6\gamma_{\min}=\pi/6γmin​=π/6, the difference x=θ1−θ2x=\theta_1-\theta_2x=θ1​−θ2​ solves x˙=1−2sin⁡x\dot x=1-2\sin xx˙=1−2sinx, and from x(0)=π/2x(0)=\pi/2x(0)=π/2 it decreases to the equilibrium π/6\pi/6π/6 without reaching it; the corrected clause says that Δˉ(γ)\bar\Delta(\gamma)Δˉ(γ) is reached for every γ>γmin⁡\gamma>\gamma_{\min}γ>γmin​. (ii) "θ˙∞∈[θ˙min⁡(0),θ˙max⁡(0)]\dot\theta_\infty\in[\dot\theta_{\min}(0),\dot\theta_{\max}(0)]θ˙∞​∈[θ˙min​(0),θ˙max​(0)] for every θ(0)∈Δ(γmax⁡)\theta(0)\in\Delta(\gamma_{\max})θ(0)∈Δ(γmax​)" fails: for n=2n=2n=2, D≡1D\equiv1D≡1, ω≡0\omega\equiv0ω≡0, P12=P21=1P_{12}=P_{21}=1P12​=P21​=1, φ12=φ21=1/2\varphi_{12}=\varphi_{21}=1/2φ12​=φ21​=1/2, condition (26) holds, θ(0)=(2.4,0)∈Δ(γmax⁡)\theta(0)=(2.4,0)\in\Delta(\gamma_{\max})θ(0)=(2.4,0)∈Δ(γmax​) has θ˙(0)≈(−0.239,0.946)\dot\theta(0)\approx(-0.239,0.946)θ˙(0)≈(−0.239,0.946) but θ˙∞=−sin⁡12≈−0.479\dot\theta_\infty=-\sin\frac12\approx-0.479θ˙∞​=−sin21​≈−0.479. The range bound is stated for θ(0)∈Δ(π/2−φmax⁡)\theta(0)\in\Delta(\pi/2-\varphi_{\max})θ(0)∈Δ(π/2−φmax​), where Theorem V.1 1) gives it; exponential synchronization is stated for every θ(0)∈Δ(γmax⁡)\theta(0)\in\Delta(\gamma_{\max})θ(0)∈Δ(γmax​), with one limit θ˙∞\dot\theta_\inftyθ˙∞​ for both parts. Arc sets are stated on real lifts of the phases; γmin⁡=arcsin⁡c\gamma_{\min}=\arcsin cγmin​=arcsinc, γmax⁡=π−arcsin⁡c\gamma_{\max}=\pi-\arcsin cγmax​=π−arcsinc with c=cos⁡(φmax⁡)Γcritical/Γmin⁡c=\cos(\varphi_{\max})\Gamma_{\mathrm{critical}}/\Gamma_{\min}c=cos(φmax​)Γcritical​/Γmin​ (the milestone gamma_min_max shows these are the unique solutions in the stated ranges); n≥2n\ge2n≥2 and Pii=φii=0P_{ii}=\varphi_{ii}=0Pii​=φii​=0 are the page's conventions made explicit.

Preamble
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_NonuniformKuramoto_CondI_Model
import Definitions.Def_NonuniformKuramoto_CondI_Constants
Formal statement
namespace NonuniformKuramoto.CondI

/-- Theorem V.3 (Synchronization condition I), pp. 19–20, with the two printed clauses that are false
as stated replaced by their corrected forms (see the item's Formalization Note):
1) `∆̄(γ)` is positively invariant for every `γ ∈ [γ_min, γ_max]`, and every solution with
   `θ(0) ∈ ∆(γ_max)` enters and stays in `∆̄(γ)` for every `γ ∈ ]γ_min, γ_max]` (asymptotic reading of
   "reaches `∆̄(γ_min)`");
2) every solution with `θ(0) ∈ ∆(γ_max)` achieves exponential frequency synchronization to some
   `θ̇_∞`, and `θ̇_∞ ∈ [θ̇_min(0), θ̇_max(0)]` whenever moreover `θ(0) ∈ ∆(π/2 − ϕ_max)`. -/
theorem theorem_V_3 {n : ℕ} (hn : 2 ≤ n) (D ω : Fin n → ℝ) (P ϕ : Fin n → Fin n → ℝ)
    (hD : ∀ i, 0 < D i) (hPsymm : ∀ i j, P i j = P j i)
    (hP : ∀ i j, i ≠ j → 0 < P i j) (hPii : ∀ i, P i i = 0) (hϕii : ∀ i, ϕ i i = 0)
    (hϕ : ∀ i j, i ≠ j → 0 ≤ ϕ i j ∧ ϕ i j < Real.pi / 2)
    (h26 : GammaCrit D ω P ϕ < GammaMin D P ϕ) :
    (∀ γ ∈ Set.Icc (gammaMin D ω P ϕ) (gammaMax D ω P ϕ),
      IsPosInvariant D ω P ϕ (ArcClosed γ)) ∧
    ∀ θ : ℝ → Fin n → ℝ, IsSolution D ω P ϕ θ → ArcOpen (gammaMax D ω P ϕ) (θ 0) →
      (∀ γ ∈ Set.Ioc (gammaMin D ω P ϕ) (gammaMax D ω P ϕ),
        ∃ T : ℝ, 0 ≤ T ∧ ∀ t : ℝ, T ≤ t → ArcClosed γ (θ t)) ∧
      ∃ ωinf C r : ℝ, 0 < r ∧
        (∀ t : ℝ, 0 ≤ t → ∀ i, |field D ω P ϕ (θ t) i - ωinf| ≤ C * Real.exp (-r * t)) ∧
        (ArcOpen (Real.pi / 2 - phiMax ϕ) (θ 0) →
          (∃ i, field D ω P ϕ (θ 0) i ≤ ωinf) ∧ (∃ i, ωinf ≤ field D ω P ϕ (θ 0) i)) := by sorry

end NonuniformKuramoto.CondI
Source
Dörfler & Bullo, Synchronization and Transient Stability in Power Networks and Nonuniform Kuramoto Oscillators, arXiv:0910.5673v4, pp. 19–20, Theorem V.3 (= Theorem III.2 1)–2), p. 9; see p. 27); proof pp. 21–22
Human review
  • Endorsed by Shuze Chen · Oct 7, 2026

    Confirmed by the moderator at approval.

  • Endorsed by mikedeng1 · Oct 7, 2026

    Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me