PM ✱1·4 (about the text): the transcribed is not a theorem of ✱1
ProvedPM.meta_perm_variant_not_thmDRAFT — part of an in-progress public formalization of Principia Mathematica; it may still change, and every change is dated in the project's change log.
A check on the text of ✱1·4 (Perm). PM's primitive proposition ✱1·4 is, in the 1910 print (Vol. I, p. 100),
The Gutenberg #78050 transcription prints in place of . Let and be two distinct propositional variables. Then the transcribed formula
is not a theorem of ✱1 (not derivable from ✱1·2–✱1·6 by ✱1·1, with the 1910 ✱1·4).
This records, as a checked fact, that the one-letter variant is a transcription slip and not a reading of PM: the card for ✱1·4 follows the print.
Formalization Note and are the variables named "p" and "q" (F.var "p", F.var "q"), introduced by local notation.
Source: PM.star1_4_variant_not_a_theorem.
import Definitions.Def_PM_core_star1_system open PM open F local notation "p" => F.var "p" local notation "q" => F.var "q" local notation "r" => F.var "r"
theorem PM.meta_perm_variant_not_thm : ¬ Thm (imp (.or p q) (.or p p)) := by sorry