Jech, Lemma 8.4 — the diagonal intersection of clubs is club
ProvedJechSetTheory.isClub_diagInterLet be a regular uncountable cardinal. Recall that is closed unbounded (club) if it is unbounded in and contains all its limit points below , and that the diagonal intersection of a family of subsets of is
Lemma (Jech 8.4). If is closed unbounded in for every , then is closed unbounded in .
Equivalently (Jech, Corollary 8.5) the closed unbounded filter on is normal. Normality is what makes the club filter rigid enough to support the pressing-down argument of Fodor's theorem, and with it the whole theory of stationary sets; the dual statement is that the nonstationary ideal is closed under diagonal unions.
Formalization Note Clubs live on the type Below k of ordinals below , so the family is indexed by that same type and the side condition of equation (8.3) is carried by the type rather than by a hypothesis. The regularity and uncountability of are hypotheses of the statement, as in Jech's standing assumption for Definition 8.1.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_JechStationary open Cardinal Order Set JechSetTheory
namespace JechSetTheory
theorem isClub_diagInter (k : Cardinal) (hk : k.IsRegular) (hk₀ : ℵ₀ < k)
(X : Below k → Set (Below k)) (hX : ∀ a, IsClub (X a)) :
IsClub (diagInter X) := by sorry
end JechSetTheoryRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic)
Provenance notice — this read-back is NOT blind and NOT independent. It was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statement it describes, at the explicit instruction of the mission owner, rather than by an independent auditor with no knowledge of the intended statement. It therefore carries none of the evidential weight of independent testimony and must not be read as a confirmation of faithfulness: the author already knew what the code was meant to say and cannot rule out having read that intent into the code. Please treat it as an annotated restatement by the author, and commission an independent read-back before relying on it in review.
Fix a cardinal subject to two hypotheses: is regular in Mathlib's sense (that is, and the cofinality of the ordinal equals ), and . Let denote the well-ordered type of ordinals strictly below .
Let be an arbitrary family assigning to each a subset , and assume that every is a club subset of , where "club" is Mathlib's predicate: is cofinal in , and closed under suprema of directed subsets of (the order-theoretic rendering of "closed" for the order topology).
The conclusion is that the set
is itself a club subset of in exactly that same sense: cofinal in and closed under suprema of its directed subsets.
Two things the quantifiers silently include. First, the family is indexed by all of , so there are exactly sets in it. Second, the least element of lies in vacuously; this is a statement about the set as a whole, not about which particular ordinals it contains.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.