Remarks after Theorem 6, p. 909 — a Polish space with a closed linear order in which (17) fails
ProvedStochIneqPO.Monotone.remark_example_not_regular17Let with the metric induced by and the linear ordering in which for all . Then:
- is a closed subset of , hence complete; it is separable (second countable); so is a Polish space;
- the ordering is closed: is closed in ;
- the ordering satisfies
- does not satisfy condition (17).
The example shows that the second part of Theorem 6 is not vacuous: there are Polish spaces with a closed partial ordering in which some nondecreasing sequence of random elements converges in probability but not almost surely.
Formalization Note The space is RemarkSpace (the subtype with the linear order pulled back along an injective rank; see that definition). Closedness of is stated in with Mathlib's product topology, which is the topology of . Completeness, second countability and closedness of the order are part of the claim and are not assumed as instances. Item 3 records that the order is the paper's. The Lean index is the paper's .
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_StochIneqPO_Monotone_Regular17 import Definitions.Def_StochIneqPO_Monotone_RemarkSpace
namespace StochIneqPO.Monotone
theorem remark_example_not_regular17 :
IsClosed remarkSet ∧ CompleteSpace RemarkSpace ∧
SecondCountableTopology RemarkSpace ∧ OrderClosedTopology RemarkSpace ∧
(∀ k : ℕ, RemarkSpace.x k < RemarkSpace.y k ∧ RemarkSpace.y k < RemarkSpace.x (k + 1) ∧
RemarkSpace.x (k + 1) < RemarkSpace.z) ∧
¬ Regular17 RemarkSpace := by sorry
end StochIneqPO.Monotone
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.