The Jones unknot conjecture is false
OpenJonesUnknot.jones_unknot_conjecture_falsejones-polynomialknot-theoryopen-problem
The Jones unknot conjecture is false: there is a nontrivial knot whose normalized Jones polynomial is .
Concretely, there exists a planar diagram (PD) code such that
- is a valid single-component knot diagram (
IsKnot) and is planar (Planar); - its normalized Jones polynomial is , i.e. (equivalently );
- its Seifert genus is positive, , so the knot is genuinely knotted and not the unknot.
This is the bare negation of the conjecture that the unknot is the only knot with Jones polynomial , and the goal of the FrontierMath open problem. The statement leaves the crossing number unfixed.
Formalization Note. is used in place of because for a knot the exponents of are multiples of and ; nontriviality is the knot invariant seifertGenus (minimum over the Reidemeister class), not the canonical genus of .
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ManolescuPiccirillo_PD import Definitions.Def_ManolescuPiccirillo_Kirby import Definitions.Def_ManolescuPiccirillo_Lee1 import Definitions.Def_JonesUnknot_planar import Definitions.Def_JonesUnknot_jones import Definitions.Def_JonesUnknot_genus open ManolescuPiccirillo JonesUnknot
Formal statement
namespace JonesUnknot
theorem jones_unknot_conjecture_false :
∃ D : PD, D.IsKnot ∧ Planar D ∧ jonesA D = 1 ∧ 0 < seifertGenus D := by sorry
end JonesUnknotSource
Epoch AI FrontierMath, The Jones Unknot Conjecture, https://epoch.ai/frontiermath/open-problems/jones-unknot (Prompt and Diagram format sections).