Proposition 3.15 — without (strong) negative type, distance covariance fails to characterize independence
ProvedDistCov.Converse.proposition_3_15Let and be separable metric spaces, and suppose has at least two points.
- If is not of negative type, there is a Borel probability measure on whose marginals have finite first moments and such that
- If is not of strong negative type, there is a Borel probability measure on whose marginals have finite first moments and such that
yet is not a product measure.
Theorem 3.11 of the paper says that on spaces of strong negative type, forces to be the product of its marginals, so that distance covariance characterizes independence. This proposition shows that the hypothesis on cannot be dropped: without negative type distance covariance can be negative, and without strong negative type it can vanish on a dependent law.
Formalization Note. Separability of and is the standing assumption of the author's Errata (i); it makes measurable for the product Borel -field. "For every metric space with at least two points" is rendered by taking as a universally quantified parameter, with the hypothesis that it has two distinct points; is chosen after . "Not a product measure" means differs from the product of its own marginals. Part 2's hypothesis is the bare negation of strong negative type and so covers spaces of negative type as well as spaces that fail it.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_DistCov_Converse_Setting open MeasureTheory
namespace DistCov.Converse
theorem proposition_3_15
{X : Type*} [MetricSpace X] [MeasurableSpace X] [BorelSpace X] [SecondCountableTopology X]
{Y : Type*} [MetricSpace Y] [MeasurableSpace Y] [BorelSpace Y] [SecondCountableTopology Y]
(hY : ∃ y₁ y₂ : Y, y₁ ≠ y₂) :
(¬ DistCov.Indep.NegType X → ∃ θ : Measure (X × Y), IsProbabilityMeasure θ ∧
DistCov.Indep.FiniteFirstMoment (θ.map Prod.fst) ∧ DistCov.Indep.FiniteFirstMoment (θ.map Prod.snd) ∧ DistCov.Indep.dcov θ < 0) ∧
(¬ DistCov.Indep.StrongNegType X → ∃ θ : Measure (X × Y), IsProbabilityMeasure θ ∧
DistCov.Indep.FiniteFirstMoment (θ.map Prod.fst) ∧ DistCov.Indep.FiniteFirstMoment (θ.map Prod.snd) ∧
DistCov.Indep.dcov θ = 0 ∧ ¬ DistCov.Indep.IsProduct θ) := by sorry
end DistCov.Converse
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.