ER = EPR, quantitative form.
ProvedEmergentGeometry.ER_EPR_throataether-catalognovelty
ER = EPR, quantitative form. Two entangled boundary cells are joined by an Einstein–Rosen bridge whose cross-section is at least half their mutual information.
theorem EmergentGeometry.ER_EPR_throat(M : HoloModel V) {u v : V} (huv : u ≠ v)
(h : 0 < mutualInfo M (single u) (single v)) :
0 < throat M.toBulkGraph (single u) (single v) ∧
BulkPath M.toBulkGraph u v ∧
mutualInfo M (single u) (single v) / 2
≤ throat M.toBulkGraph (single u) (single v) := by sorry
Formalization Note Transplanted verbatim from the Aether Catalog source Novelty/EREPRThroatCapacity.lean; the statement is byte-identical to the source declaration, elaborated with autoImplicit disabled in the platform environment.
Preamble
-- Thm stub generated from Novelty/EREPRThroatCapacity.lean
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_EREPRBridge
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_EREPRThroatCapacity
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_EmergentGeometryEntropyCone
/-!
# Throat capacity of an Einstein–Rosen bridge and the `I ≤ 2 E_W` bound
This file adds a genuinely *geometric* observable to the min-cut model of
`Novelty.EmergentGeometryEntropyCone`: the **throat capacity**
`throat G A B = min { area(σ) : σ ⊇ A, σ ∩ B = ∅ }`,
the smallest bulk surface that has to be cut in order to disconnect the bulk
region `A` from the bulk region `B`. Unlike the entropy `S(A)` this is *not*
constrained to be homologous to a boundary region: it measures the cross-section
of the Einstein–Rosen bridge joining `A` to `B` (the discrete analogue of the
entanglement wedge cross-section `E_W`).
Main results:
* `cutWeight_eq_zero_of_closed`, `weight_eq_zero_of_cutWeight_eq_zero`:
a bulk surface has zero area iff no positive-weight edge crosses it.
* `throat_pos_iff_bulkPath` : **the throat capacity of a pair of cells is
positive exactly when an Einstein–Rosen bridge joins them.** Geometric
connectivity is detected by a single real number.
* `mutualInfo_le_two_throat` : **`I(A:B) ≤ 2 · throat(A,B)`**, the toy-model
form of the holographic inequality `I(A:B) ≤ 2 E_W(A:B)`: entanglement between
two boundary regions is bounded by the cross-section of the bridge that
connects them. Its combinatorial engine is the new pointwise Boolean
inequality `sepBit_split`.
* `throat_le_entropy`, `throat_sandwich` : `I(A:B)/2 ≤ throat(A,B) ≤ min(S A, S B)`.
* `ER_EPR_throat` : positive mutual information of two boundary cells forces a
positive-capacity Einstein–Rosen bridge between them — ER = EPR with a
quantitative bound, strengthening `bridge_of_mutualInfo_pos`.
-- !-- Lab Notes -- !--
HYPOTHESIS (Hypothesizer). In holography the entanglement wedge cross-section
`E_W` obeys `E_W ≥ I/2`. If the slogan "ER=EPR" is to have content beyond mere
connectivity, the *width* of the bridge should bound the *amount* of
entanglement, not just its (non)vanishing.
EXPERIMENT (Experimenter). We defined `throat` as an unconstrained min-cut and
looked for a recombination of Boolean regions realising the bound. The winning
combination splits the minimal surface `g` of `A ∪ B` along the minimal
separating surface `σ`: `X = σ ∧ g` is homologous to `A`, `Y = ¬σ ∧ g` to `B`.
The needed pointwise fact is `sepBit_split`, i.e.
`sep(a∧b) + sep(¬a∧b) ≤ sep(b) + 2 sep(a)`, a 16-case Boolean identity; note the
factor `2` is necessary (take `a₁ = true, a₂ = false, b₁ = b₂ = true`, where the
left side is `2` and `sep b = 0`).
ANALYSIS (Analyst). The bound is *tight*: for a single throat of weight `w`
between two boundary cells one has `throat = w` and `I = 2w`. Combined with
`throat ≤ min(S A, S B)` we obtain a two-sided sandwich, so in the toy model the
bridge cross-section is squeezed between half the mutual information and the
entropies of its two mouths.
CRITIQUE (Critic). `throat` is a `dite` over a possibly empty family; all
statements that use its minimality carry the disjointness hypothesis that makes
the family nonempty, and none of them is vacuous (`pairModel_throat` exhibits a
model where every hypothesis holds and the value is nonzero).
-/
noncomputable section
open EmergentGeometry
open Finset
variable {V : Type*} [Fintype V] [DecidableEq V]
/-! ## Surfaces separating two bulk regions -/
/-! ## Monotonicity in the amount of entanglement -/
/-! ## Zero-area surfaces and bulk connectivity -/
/-! ## The bound `I(A:B) ≤ 2 · throat(A,B)` -/Formal statement
theorem EmergentGeometry.ER_EPR_throat(M : HoloModel V) {u v : V} (huv : u ≠ v)
(h : 0 < mutualInfo M (single u) (single v)) :
0 < throat M.toBulkGraph (single u) (single v) ∧
BulkPath M.toBulkGraph u v ∧
mutualInfo M (single u) (single v) / 2
≤ throat M.toBulkGraph (single u) (single v) := by sorrySource