Claim — the tail coefficients are all equal to 1
DisprovedToricFoliations.tail_coefficients_eq_onetheorem_title: Claim — the tail coefficients are all equal to 1
In the setting of Theorem 1.3, suppose the extremal ray satisfies and let be the torus-invariant curve of the ray after the reordering (3.2). Let the tail indices be , i.e. the last indices of the wall relation. If each tail vector lies in , then the corresponding coefficients in the wall relation (3.1) are all equal to 1:
This is the Claim of the paper (between equations (3.9) and (3.10)); its proof is a divisibility argument using the multiplicities of the cones and .
Formalization Note. tailIndex hr j is the Lean index of
for 0 ≤ j ≤ r; the hypothesis is that every
toComplex (C.v (tailIndex hr j)) lies in V.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ToricFoliations open scoped BigOperators
namespace ToricFoliations
/--
The Claim in the proof of Theorem 1.3: in the long-ray case, once the tail
indices `n-r+1,...,n+1` (Lean: `tailIndex hr j`) are known to lie in `V`,
the wall relation forces
`a_{n-r+1} = ... = a_{n+1} = 1`.
This is the divisibility argument following equation (3.9) of the paper.
-/
theorem tail_coefficients_eq_one {n r : ℕ} (hr : r ≤ n) (C : WallData n)
(V : Submodule ℂ (Complexified n))
(hrank : Module.finrank ℂ V = r)
(hlong : r < curveLength C V)
(htail : ∀ j : Fin (r + 1), toComplex (C.v (tailIndex hr j)) ∈ V) :
∀ j : Fin (r + 1), C.a (tailIndex hr j) = 1 := by
sorry
end ToricFoliationsRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-haiku-4-5
Fix with , let be an element of , and let be a -submodule of . Unfolding: ; consists of a proof , vectors and integer coefficients for , subject to , positivity/monotonicity/multiplicity/B'ezout side conditions; is the coordinatewise inclusion . The hypotheses assert: (1) ; (2) , where unfolding gives the rational sum, over , of when (embedded in ) and otherwise, with if , else (division in ); (3) for every , i.e. , the embedded tail vector lies in . Here is the 0-based index in , the positions of the paper vectors . The conclusion is that, for every such , as an integer. Edge cases: because carries , makes the premise impossible and the theorem vacuous; reduces the tail family to the single last index , i.e. ; makes for all . If no such satisfy the hypotheses, the implication is vacuous.