Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Section III — vertical integration of successive monopolies lowers the final price and raises output, aggregate profit and consumers' surplus

Proved
SpenglerVertical.DoubleMarginalization.vertical_integration_benefits_producer_and_consumer

by mikedeng1 · Oct 6, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

double-marginalizationindustrial-organizationmonopoly-pricingp2o-batch-pfp2bp2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1vertical-integration

Consider three successive stages of production A→B→CA\to B\to CA→B→C with fixed proportions (one unit of each stage's product per unit of the next) and constant unit variable costs Va,Vb,VcV_a,V_b,V_cVa​,Vb​,Vc​. Let DDD be a non-increasing demand curve for the final product CCC. Stage A sells to stage B at price PaP_aPa​ and stage B sells to stage C at price PbP_bPb​, each with a positive "monopolistic" profit per unit:

Ra=Pa−Va>0,Rb=Pb−(Vb+Pa)>0.R_a=P_a-V_a>0,\qquad R_b=P_b-(V_b+P_a)>0.Ra​=Pa​−Va​>0,Rb​=Pb​−(Vb​+Pa​)>0.

Without integration, stage C has unit cost Cc=Vc+PbC_c=V_c+P_bCc​=Vc​+Pb​ and charges a profit-maximizing price PcP_cPc​ at that cost; it sells Q=D(Pc)Q=D(P_c)Q=D(Pc​) units, and every stage handles the same QQQ units. A vertically integrated firm has unit cost Cc′=Va+Vb+VcC'_c=V_a+V_b+V_cCc′​=Va​+Vb​+Vc​ and charges a profit-maximizing price Pc′P'_cPc′​ at that cost, selling Q′=D(Pc′)Q'=D(P'_c)Q′=D(Pc′​). Assume DDD is differentiable at PcP_cPc​ and Q>0Q>0Q>0. Then

  1. the integrated firm lowers the price: Pc′<PcP'_c<P_cPc′​<Pc​;
  2. output rises: Q<Q′Q<Q'Q<Q′;
  3. aggregate "profit" (return above variable expense) rises:
RaQ+RbQ+RcQ<(Pc′−(Va+Vb+Vc))Q′,Rc=Pc−(Vc+Pb);R_aQ+R_bQ+R_cQ<\big(P'_c-(V_a+V_b+V_c)\big)Q',\qquad R_c=P_c-(V_c+P_b);Ra​Q+Rb​Q+Rc​Q<(Pc′​−(Va​+Vb​+Vc​))Q′,Rc​=Pc​−(Vc​+Pb​);
  1. consumers' (Marshallian) surplus rises, by at least Q(Pc−Pc′)Q(P_c-P'_c)Q(Pc​−Pc′​):
0<∫Pc′PcD(x) dx,Q (Pc−Pc′)≤∫Pc′PcD(x) dx.0<\int_{P'_c}^{P_c}D(x)\,dx,\qquad Q\,(P_c-P'_c)\le\int_{P'_c}^{P_c}D(x)\,dx.0<∫Pc′​Pc​​D(x)dx,Q(Pc​−Pc′​)≤∫Pc′​Pc​​D(x)dx.

Since Va+Vb+Vc+Ra+Rb+Rc=PcV_a+V_b+V_c+R_a+R_b+R_c=P_cVa​+Vb​+Vc​+Ra​+Rb​+Rc​=Pc​, the left side of item 3 is the chain's aggregate profit Q[Pc−(Va+Vb+Vc)]Q[P_c-(V_a+V_b+V_c)]Q[Pc​−(Va​+Vb​+Vc​)]. This is Spengler's conclusion that "vertical integration, under the conditions assumed, … benefits both producer and consumer": the integrated firm evades the surcharges Ra+RbR_a+R_bRa​+Rb​ imposed upstream, which is the double-marginalization argument against treating vertical integration as illegal per se.

Formalization Note The paper argues on Figure 1 and asserts the result "under all cases conceivable … within the framework here employed"; the statement is for an arbitrary non-increasing demand curve and arbitrary transfer prices with positive markups (PaP_aPa​, PbP_bPb​ need not themselves be profit-maximizing). Prices range over R\mathbb RR. Two readings are added: differentiability of DDD at PcP_cPc​ (the paper's marginal-revenue reasoning presupposes it; without it a kinked demand curve can leave the price unchanged) and Q>0Q>0Q>0 (the chain trades). The weak versions (≤\le≤) of items 2 and 3 need neither; the weak version of item 1 still needs Q>0Q>0Q>0 (if D≡0D\equiv0D≡0 every price is profit-maximizing). No linearity, concavity or uniqueness of maximizers is assumed.

Preamble
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_SpenglerVertical_DoubleMarginalization_Model
Formal statement
namespace SpenglerVertical.DoubleMarginalization

theorem vertical_integration_benefits_producer_and_consumer
    (D : ℝ → ℝ) (hD : Antitone D)
    (Va Vb Vc Pa Pb Pc Pc' : ℝ)
    (hRa : 0 < Pa - Va) (hRb : 0 < Pb - (Vb + Pa))
    (hPc : IsProfitMax D (Vc + Pb) Pc)
    (hPc' : IsProfitMax D (Va + Vb + Vc) Pc')
    (hdiff : DifferentiableAt ℝ D Pc) (hQ : 0 < D Pc) :
    Pc' < Pc ∧
    D Pc < D Pc' ∧
    (Pa - Va) * D Pc + (Pb - (Vb + Pa)) * D Pc + (Pc - (Vc + Pb)) * D Pc
      < (Pc' - (Va + Vb + Vc)) * D Pc' ∧
    D Pc * (Pc - Pc') ≤ ∫ x in Pc'..Pc, D x ∧
    0 < ∫ x in Pc'..Pc, D x := by sorry

end SpenglerVertical.DoubleMarginalization
Source
Spengler, Vertical integration and antitrust policy, J. Polit. Econ. 58 (1950), pp. 347–350, Sections I–III (main statement p. 350, restated p. 352, Section IV); https://doi.org/10.1086/256964
Human review
  • Endorsed by Shuze Chen · Oct 6, 2026

    Confirmed by the moderator at approval.

  • Endorsed by mikedeng1 · Oct 6, 2026

    Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me