Theorem of Necessary External Grounding
ProvedTranscendenceTower.ExternalGroundingPlatform.necessary_external_groundingLet be the type of partial recursive program codes (Nat.Partrec.Code) with universal evaluator and bounded-step evaluator , and let be the modal context language over signed atoms and context indices from Def_TranscendenceTowerContextUniformity.
The Theorem of Necessary External Grounding establishes four joint limits and guarantees for autonomous verification pipelines:
- Multi-Oracle Rice Undecidability: For every semantic specification (meaning ) that is non-trivial ( and ), every computable base verifier (
Computable d₀), and every finite pipeline of internalized computable verification sub-oracles (), there exists a program on which the conjunctive pipeline verdict disagrees with :
-
Computability of Bounded Test Harnesses: For every step bound , input , and target output , the bounded execution test is a computable sub-oracle (
Computable), so adjoining finitely many bounded test assertions into remains trapped inside Part 1. -
Closed-Loop Collapse & Undecidability under Semantic Drift: For any context-free specification (), any proposition-uniform default rule schema (
PropUniformRules S) whose consequents are consistent with , and any Reiter extension (IsExtension Ax S Ext), if a base-language requirement (IsBase G_*) holds in the target operational environment ( and ) while a drifted model satisfies () and falsifies (), then is undecidable in the closed loop :
- Soundness, Sufficiency, and Non-Uniformity of Supervisory External Grounding: Under the hypotheses of Part 3 with , for any outer operational context , the external semantic oracle injection
is consistent with (Consistent (Ax ∪ LiftAx)), certifies (), and is necessarily non-uniform ().
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerContextUniformity import Mathlib.Computability.Halting set_option autoImplicit false open Computable open Nat.Partrec (Code) open TranscendenceTower.UniformityPlatform
theorem TranscendenceTower.ExternalGroundingPlatform.necessary_external_grounding (A C : Type) :
(∀ (Spec : Set Code),
(∀ c₁ c₂ : Code, Code.eval c₁ = Code.eval c₂ → (c₁ ∈ Spec ↔ c₂ ∈ Spec)) →
((∃ c_yes : Code, c_yes ∈ Spec) ∧ (∃ c_no : Code, c_no ∉ Spec)) →
∀ (d₀ : Code → Bool) (Os : List (Code → Bool)),
Computable d₀ → (∀ O ∈ Os, Computable O) →
∃ c_star : Code,
(Os.foldl (fun acc O => acc && O c_star) (d₀ c_star) = true) ↔ c_star ∉ Spec) ∧
(∀ k x y : ℕ, Computable (fun c : Code => decide (Code.evaln k c x = some y))) ∧
(∀ (Ax : Set (CForm A C)) (S : Set (Rule A C)) (Ext : Set (CForm A C))
(v_real v_drift : CVal A C) (G_star : CForm A C),
(∀ p ∈ Ax, IsBase p) → PropUniformRules S →
Consistent (Ax ∪ {γ | ∃ r ∈ S, r.conseq = γ}) →
IsExtension Ax S Ext → IsBase G_star →
Models Ax v_real → eval v_real G_star = true →
Models Ax v_drift → eval v_drift G_star = false →
G_star ∉ Ext ∧ neg G_star ∉ Ext) ∧
(∀ (Ax : Set (CForm A C)) (v_real : CVal A C) (c_real : C) (G_star : CForm A C),
(∀ p ∈ Ax, IsBase p) → IsBase G_star →
Models Ax v_real → eval v_real G_star = true → G_star ∉ Cn Ax →
let LiftAx : Set (CForm A C) :=
{CForm.ist c_real G_star, CForm.impl (CForm.ist c_real G_star) G_star}
Consistent (Ax ∪ LiftAx) ∧ G_star ∈ Cn (Ax ∪ LiftAx) ∧ ¬ PropUniform LiftAx) := by sorry