Theorem 13.3: in the rationing game both retailers order more than the newsvendor quantity
ProvedSupplyChainTheory.rationing_nash_inflatesTheorem 13.3. Two identical retailers face single-period demand with a continuous, strictly increasing distribution function on , holding cost per unit left over and stockout penalty per lost sale, so that the newsvendor quantity satisfies . The supply is with probability , , and unlimited otherwise, with ; a shortage is rationed pro rata to the orders, retailer 1 receiving . Retailer 1's expected cost is (13.14),
with the newsvendor cost. If is a symmetric Nash equilibrium, that is minimizes over positive order quantities when retailer 2 orders , then
In the presence of possible shortages, order quantities are inflated. The book's proof sets the derivative of (13.14) to zero at the symmetric point: the rationed term contributes , which is negative because , so the unrationed term must satisfy (Eq. 13.15) against (Eq. 13.16), and strictly increasing gives . The book notes that inflated orders do not by themselves prove inflated variances; the rigorous bullwhip claim for this model is in Rong et al. (2017).
Formalization Note The demand law is a probability measure on whose distribution function is continuous and strictly increasing on ; the newsvendor loss is assumed integrable. The equilibrium is stated as optimality of against every positive with the other retailer fixed at .
import Definitions.Def_SupplyChainTheory_bullwhip
namespace SupplyChainTheory
theorem rationing_nash_inflates (h p r A1 Qstar Q : ℝ) (Dlaw : MeasureTheory.Measure ℝ)
[MeasureTheory.IsProbabilityMeasure Dlaw]
(hh : 0 < h) (hp : 0 < p) (hr0 : 0 < r) (hr1 : r < 1) (hA : 0 < A1)
(hint : ∀ y : ℝ, MeasureTheory.Integrable (fun d => h * max (y - d) 0 + p * max (d - y) 0) Dlaw)
(hFc : Continuous (ProbabilityTheory.cdf Dlaw))
(hFmono : StrictMonoOn (ProbabilityTheory.cdf Dlaw) (Set.Ici 0))
(hQs0 : 0 ≤ Qstar) (hQstar : ProbabilityTheory.cdf Dlaw Qstar = p / (h + p))
(hA2 : A1 < 2 * Qstar) (hQpos : 0 < Q)
(hNash : ∀ Q1 : ℝ, 0 < Q1 →
rationingCost h p r A1 Dlaw Q Q ≤ rationingCost h p r A1 Dlaw Q Q1) :
Qstar < Q := by sorry
end SupplyChainTheory
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.