Wavelength and frequency forms of Planck's law differ by the Jacobian
ProvedBlackbodyRadiation.planckWave_eq_jacobian_mul_planckFreqPlanck's law has a frequency form and a wavelength form , and they are different functions. Because a spectral radiance is a density — radiance per increment of its own spectral variable — one cannot pass from one to the other by the substitution alone; the Jacobian of the change of variable must be included.
This milestone records the exact relation. For positive and positive , and for arbitrary , , ,
the factor being at . It is this factor that shifts the peak of the distribution, so that the wavelength curve and the frequency curve, at the same temperature, attain their maxima at physically different places.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_BlackbodyRadiation_planck
namespace BlackbodyRadiation
theorem planckWave_eq_jacobian_mul_planckFreq
(h c kB T lam : ℝ) (hc : 0 < c) (hlam : 0 < lam) :
planckWave h c kB T lam = c / lam ^ 2 * planckFreq h c kB T (c / lam) := by sorry
end BlackbodyRadiationRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic) — same agent as the statement author, non-blind
Disclosure — non-blind read-back. This read-back was not written by an independent blind auditor. It was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statement it describes, with full knowledge of the intended meaning and of the source material. It is therefore self-testimony, not independent testimony, and it cannot be relied on to catch a mismatch between intent and formalization in the way a blind read-back is designed to. Please read it as a convenience rendering only, and audit the Lean statement directly.
The claim is an identity between two real numbers, asserted for all real , , ,
and (written lam) subject to exactly two hypotheses: and
. No hypothesis at all is placed on , on , or on ; in particular
they may be zero or negative.
The two functions involved are the ones fixed by the accompanying definition bundle:
and
both total functions in which a division by zero yields .
The asserted equation is
i.e. the wavelength-form value equals times the frequency-form value taken at the frequency . The right-hand side is a product of the scalar with a single application of the frequency function; the substituted frequency argument is literally .
Degenerate cases permitted by the hypotheses are included in the claim. If , then in both functions the argument of the exponential is a quotient with denominator , hence , so each exponential equals , each outer denominator equals , and both sides are ; the equation holds but says nothing about black-body radiation. The same collapse occurs when . The statement asserts no positivity, no monotonicity, and no maximization property: it is a pointwise algebraic identity only, and it is an equality of values, not of functions.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.