Theorem 1.3(2) — long extremal rays give a -bundle and
DisprovedToricFoliations.projective_space_bundletheorem_title: Theorem 1.3(2) — long extremal rays give a -bundle and
Let be a projective -factorial toric variety and let be a toric foliation of rank on , represented by . Let be an extremal ray of . If
then the extremal contraction associated to is a -bundle over , the foliation is the relative tangent sheaf of , and in particular is locally free and .
In the combinatorial core formalized here, the -bundle
conclusion is the statement that the tail vectors
satisfy , span a saturated rank- sublattice of
, and give a lattice splitting
(IsProjectiveSpaceBundle), and that
the length on every curve of the ray equals .
Formalization Note. The sheaf-theoretic wrapper (contracting morphisms,
relative tangent sheaf) is not yet in Mathlib; ExtremalRay.isExtremal marks
the boundary where the toric Mori theory attaches. Nothing in the statement is
vacuous: WallData carries real content and hlong is the nontrivial
hypothesis of the theorem.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ToricFoliations open scoped BigOperators
namespace ToricFoliations
/--
Theorem 1.3(2) of the paper (main theorem): if the length of an extremal ray
`R` satisfies `l_F(R) > r`, then the associated extremal contraction is a
`P^r`-bundle, the foliation is the relative tangent sheaf of that contraction,
and in particular `l_F(R) = r + 1`.
In this combinatorial core the `P^r`-bundle conclusion is encoded by the
lattice splitting and tail-vector span of `IsProjectiveSpaceBundle`.
-/
theorem projective_space_bundle {n r : ℕ} (hr : r ≤ n) (R : ExtremalRay n)
(hExt : R.isExtremal) (C : WallData n) (hC : C ∈ R.curves)
(V : Submodule ℂ (Complexified n))
(hrank : Module.finrank ℂ V = r)
(hlong : r < rayLength R V) :
IsProjectiveSpaceBundle hr C ∧ curveLength C V = r + 1 := by
sorry
end ToricFoliationsRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-haiku-4-5
Fix with , and fix of type ExtremalRay n: a record carrying a nonempty finite set of wall-data objects together with a proposition field . Thus merely asserts that opaque proposition, and the record's nonempty field rules out an empty ray. Fix ; being wall data means: ; vectors and integers for satisfy , and , ; positive multiplicities satisfy and ; and some integers give . Fix , a -subspace of Complexified n (functions ), with . The length is the rational sum over of if , otherwise of , contributed only when the lattice vector , coerced into , lies in . Then is the minimum of these lengths over the nonempty , and asserts .
The conclusion asserts two things. First, IsProjectiveSpaceBundle holds for the proof and : (i) with indices for , ; (ii) the -span of those tail vectors is isomorphic (as a -module) to ; (iii) there is a -module isomorphism . Second, as rationals. Degenerate cases: is impossible because wall data require ; and are both allowed, with requiring the single tail vector to sum to and span a rank- module, while makes the tail range all indices.