Lifting is route-dependent: a transfer that succeeds directly can fail through an intermediary
ProvedTranscendenceTower.Chaining.lifting_does_not_chainDoes lifting compose? If a fact travels from one context to a second, and from the second to a third, does it arrive by the same route it would have taken directly?
It does not, and the reason is structural. Lifting carries a context's assertions across, so a two-step route deposits the intermediate context's own commitments into the destination alongside those of the origin. Those extra commitments can conflict with the destination even when the origin does not.
Take three contexts:
Observe first that and are entirely compatible — and hold together. There is no conflict between the endpoints.
Directly, transfers to and does so determinately: nothing need be blocked, the empty blocking set is therefore minimal, and is a consequence of the result.
Through , it does not. The first hop carries along, so what arrives at is rather than , and that conflicts. Two incomparable minimal blocking sets appear — give up , or give up — and in the first of them does not survive.
So lifting is route-dependent. The specializes relation composes perfectly well as a relation between contexts, but what it transfers does not compose along with it: which path a fact took is part of what arrived.
This sharpens the multiple-extensions result rather than repeating it. There, indeterminacy arose because the destination genuinely conflicted with the origin, which is unsurprising. Here the origin and destination are compatible, and the indeterminacy is manufactured entirely by passing through an intermediary. A theory of contexts therefore cannot treat specializes as something to be chained freely in order to reach a distant context.
Retired because it is superseded by TranscendenceTower.Chaining.lifting_is_route_sensitive, whose statement makes the intended semantic strength explicit.
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerLiftConflicts set_option autoImplicit false open TranscendenceTower TranscendenceTower.ContextTheories TranscendenceTower.Lifting
namespace TranscendenceTower.Chaining
theorem lifting_does_not_chain :
(MinBlock srcP tgtNand ∅ ∧ pA ∈ Cn (Lift srcP tgtNand ∅))
∧ Lift srcP {qA} ∅ = srcPQ
∧ MinBlock srcPQ tgtNand {pA}
∧ MinBlock srcPQ tgtNand {qA}
∧ pA ∉ Cn (Lift srcPQ tgtNand {pA}) := by sorry
end TranscendenceTower.Chaining