Equal entropy triples with different mixed-state entanglement
ProvedQAlgorithms.Papers.Independent.Support50.P42.entropy_triple_counterexampleWrite . On two spins per observer define and , regrouping Alice's two spins against Bob's two spins. Both are normalized density matrices and satisfy
The state is separable, whereas is entangled; discarding the second spin locally on both sides of leaves exactly a singlet. Thus the subsystem and total entropy triple does not determine mixed-state entanglement. The uncorrelated second pair is explicitly maximally mixed.
import Definitions.Def_QAlgorithms_Papers_Independent_Support50_P42
noncomputable section
namespace QAlgorithms.Papers.Independent.Support50.P42
open scoped BigOperators Matrix ComplexConjugate
open MeasureTheory ProbabilityTheory
attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable Classical.decEq
-- Reuse the exact accepted objects, without introducing same-name aliases.
open Information100.P21 (Op Vec FiniteLOCC)
open Dependency50.P42 (dimensionedPower singlets)
open Dependency50.P48 (pureFidelity)
open Gap48.P32 (pairOfState)
open Next46.P39 (rectAct)
/-- PDF p.16: two four-spin mixed states with all three entropies equal to two.
The second uncorrelated pair is maximally mixed. The first state is separable;
the second is entangled and yields a singlet upon local disposal. -/
theorem entropy_triple_counterexample :
let rho := twoPairs classicalPair classicalPair
let sigma := twoPairs Dependency50.P42.singletState ((1/4 : ℂ) • 1)
IsDensityMatrix rho ∧ IsDensityMatrix sigma ∧
vnEntropy rho=2 ∧ vnEntropy (traceLeft rho)=2 ∧ vnEntropy (traceRight rho)=2 ∧
vnEntropy sigma=2 ∧ vnEntropy (traceLeft sigma)=2 ∧ vnEntropy (traceRight sigma)=2 ∧
Entanglement.IsSeparablePositive rho ∧ ¬Entanglement.IsSeparablePositive sigma ∧
discardSecond sigma=Dependency50.P42.singletState := by sorry
end QAlgorithms.Papers.Independent.Support50.P42
end
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · gpt-6.1-sol
Let , let , and put
where the grouped product is defined by , so each party has local dimension four. Both and are positive semidefinite and have trace one, and
Here , with zero eigenvalues contributing zero. The matrix is a finite sum with and local positive semidefinite trace-one matrices , whereas admits no such sum; this separability condition does not separately require . Finally, tracing out both second-pair coordinates of gives , explicitly
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.