Rational rays force algebraic dependence: exclusivity in the pair dichotomy
ProvedDiaz.pair_dichotomy_exclusiveLet be such that is algebraic over , and let be a non-zero rational multiple of either or :
Then and are algebraically dependent over .
Where this sits. This is the opening step of the proof of Carlo Perassi's pair dichotomy (rational proportionality or independence) — the clause that makes the dichotomy exclusive. The dichotomy asserts that for on the Diaz locus with , exactly one of
- (i) ,
- (ii) and are algebraically independent over
holds. The implication (i) (ii) is this node, and it is unconditional: it uses no transcendence input whatever. The opposite direction (ii) (i) is the deep half — it passes through Théorème 0.2 of Roy–Waldschmidt (1997), which is not available in this Mathlib revision, and then through the linear-algebra step already published as Diaz.rational_singular_subspace_classification and Diaz.rational_subspace_quadric_ratios. It also follows from Theorem 6.7 of Carlo Perassi's companion note to https://github.com/carlok/diaz-modulus-lean (version 1.10, 27 September 2026, GitHub release note-v1.10), on this mission as the Proved node DiazModulus.log_pair_rigid_of_trdeg_one, because on the Diaz locus and with algebraic numerators, so .
Proof. Write .
Case , . The non-zero polynomial vanishes at .
Case , . Then , which is algebraic over because is and is rational. Let , a non-zero polynomial with , and set . Then
and because the substitution is an injective -algebra map — it admits the left inverse , , under which .
In both cases a non-zero rational polynomial annihilates , so the pair is not algebraically independent.
Formalisation notes. "Algebraically dependent over " is rendered ¬ AlgebraicIndependent ℚ ![u, v]. Two hypotheses of the original setting are deliberately not assumed, because the argument does not use them: (the statement holds for too, where itself annihilates the pair), and the algebraicity of . Only is used, so the node applies verbatim off the Diaz locus.
Source. Carlo Perassi, unpublished apart from this node. The mathematics is his; this node records one step of it in Lean and claims no novelty of its own. Elementary.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_Diaz_Closure import Definitions.Def_Diaz_Instantiation open ComplexConjugate open Diaz
theorem Diaz.pair_dichotomy_exclusive {u v : ℂ}
(hq : IsAlgebraic ℚ (u * conj u))
(h : (∃ c : ℚ, c ≠ 0 ∧ v = (c : ℂ) * u) ∨
(∃ c : ℚ, c ≠ 0 ∧ v = (c : ℂ) * conj u)) :
¬ AlgebraicIndependent ℚ ![u, v] := by sorry