Holographic strong subadditivity, eq. (3.1) — both inequalities
ProvedHolographicSSA.holographic_strong_subadditivityLet be a topological space (the constant-time slice of the bulk, cut off at a finite value of the holographic coordinate) carrying a measure (the area) for which every open set is measurable, let be its conformal-boundary part, let be Newton's constant, and let be a class of bulk regions. For let
be the holographic entanglement entropy (2.1) with the homology rule. Then for all :
- if is closed under union and intersection, then
- if is closed under set difference, then
These are the two forms (3.1) of strong subadditivity, the property every quantum entanglement entropy has; the theorem shows that the Ryu–Takayanagi prescription has it for every static bulk geometry, which is the paper's consistency check of holographic entanglement entropy.
Formalization Note Both inequalities are stated in . Each closure hypothesis on is attached only to the inequality that uses it, so the first inequality also covers classes (such as closed sets) that are not closed under difference.
Differences from the source:
- generalization: a static bulk slice cut off at finite holographic coordinate, with conformal boundary → an arbitrary topological space and an arbitrary subset ; reason: the paper's slice is a topological space and its cutoff boundary a subset of it
- generalization: the area → an arbitrary measure on with open sets measurable; reason: the paper notes the argument holds for "any extensive functional of the hypersurface" (p.6), and the Riemannian area (a multiple of ) is such a measure
- generalization: regions of the bulk → an arbitrary class , closed under and for the first inequality and under for the second; reason: the proof uses only these closures (3.2); the class of all subsets satisfies both
- generalization: boundary regions → arbitrary subsets ; reason: for no region is homologous to , so and the inequalities hold; for boundary regions they are the paper's
- encoding: over hypersurfaces homologous to → times the infimum in of over with , the frontier in ; reason: the definition's convention (the minimum, when it exists, is the infimum; is read as frontier plus the homology rule)
- encoding: with the complement in the boundary → in ; reason: the same set, since does not depend on the ambient space of the complement
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_HolographicSSA_holographicEntropy open MeasureTheory
namespace HolographicSSA
/-- **Holographic strong subadditivity** (Headrick, Takayanagi, *A holographic proof of the strong
subadditivity of entanglement entropy*, arXiv:0704.3719v1, §3, eq. (3.1), p.5): "We begin by
rewriting the inequalities (1.3) in the forms S(A) + S(B) ≥ S(A ∪ B) + S(A ∩ B) ,
S(A) + S(B) ≥ S(A \ B) + S(B \ A) , (3.1) where A \ B ≡ A ∩ Bc."
Let `X` be a topological space (the cut-off bulk slice) with a measure `μ` (the area) whose open
sets are measurable, `Γ ⊆ X` its conformal-boundary part, `0 < G` (Newton's constant), and `𝓡` a
class of bulk regions. Writing `S = holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡`, for all `A, B ⊆ X`:
1. if `𝓡` is closed under `∪` and `∩`, then `S (A ∪ B) + S (A ∩ B) ≤ S A + S B`;
2. if `𝓡` is closed under `\`, then `S (A \ B) + S (B \ A) ≤ S A + S B`.
**Formalization Note** See `HolographicSSA.holographicEntropy` for the encoding (frontier in `X` as
the surface, `r ∩ Γ = A` as the homology rule, an arbitrary measure as the area, `⨅` in `ℝ≥0∞` as
`min`). Each closure hypothesis is attached only to the inequality whose proof uses it. -/
theorem holographic_strong_subadditivity {X : Type*} [TopologicalSpace X] [MeasurableSpace X]
[OpensMeasurableSpace X] (Γ : Set X) (μ : Measure X) (G : ℝ) (hG : 0 < G)
(𝓡 : Set (Set X)) (A B : Set X) :
((∀ r ∈ 𝓡, ∀ s ∈ 𝓡, r ∪ s ∈ 𝓡 ∧ r ∩ s ∈ 𝓡) →
holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 (A ∪ B) + holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 (A ∩ B) ≤
holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 A + holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 B) ∧
((∀ r ∈ 𝓡, ∀ s ∈ 𝓡, r \ s ∈ 𝓡) →
holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 (A \ B) + holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 (B \ A) ≤
holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 A + holographicEntropy Γ μ G 𝓡 B) := by sorry
end HolographicSSA
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.