Proposition 2, p. 14 — a truth-revealing equilibrium exists iff Σ µ(m|H)a_m ≤ [1 + η(1/θ_H + 1/θ_L − 1)]w ≤ Σ µ(m|L)a_m
ProvedYieldCheapTalk.Truthful.proposition_2Consider Lu's cheap-talk game: a supplier of privately known yield type (mean yields , common coefficient of variation ) sends a costless, unverifiable report of her type to a buyer who privately knows the market state (market potentials , inverse demand ), and the buyer then orders under the contract . Let be the probability of state given type . Under the standing assumptions of the model, a truth-revealing perfect Bayesian equilibrium exists — that is, there are an ordering strategy and beliefs forming a PBE with the truthful messaging strategy — if and only if
This is the paper's main existence result: the supplier's yield risk can be credibly communicated by cheap talk exactly when the expected market potential conditional on each type brackets the adjusted wholesale rate. In particular (6) requires the low type to expect a higher market potential than the high type.
Formalization Note. The standing assumptions are those of §3 together with , which the paper assumes from p. 12 on; the equivalence itself does not use . and are added; with the model forces , so and are genuine reciprocals. The equilibrium is the paper's PBE (pp. 8–9) with optimality of the order over all and beliefs that are probability distributions; the statement is not the equivalence of (5) and (6), which is a step of its proof.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_YieldCheapTalk_Truthful_Setting open MeasureTheory
namespace YieldCheapTalk.Truthful
theorem proposition_2 (M : Model) (hM : M.Standing) :
(∃ (Q : Level → Level → ℝ) (beta : Level → Level → Level → ℝ), M.IsPBE id Q beta) ↔
(∑ m, M.mu m .H * M.a m ≤ (1 + M.eta * (1 / M.theta .H + 1 / M.theta .L - 1)) * M.w ∧
(1 + M.eta * (1 / M.theta .H + 1 / M.theta .L - 1)) * M.w ≤
∑ m, M.mu m .L * M.a m) := by sorry
end YieldCheapTalk.Truthful
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.