Conditional extension of a finite side pattern
DefinitionAPFB05_FreeWhereNovelapfapf-referencesib-v52-2026-11
FreeWhereNovel requires a novel distinction to take both sides while preserving the existing finite readings at each starting state.
Meaning and scope
The novelty predicate is supplied. This conditioned candidate was never adopted; it is vacuous when X is empty and does not by itself supply a starting state.
Status: conditional reference mathematics. The supplied predicates and model assumptions are not additional Foundation inputs. These records do not establish K1, K3 or K4 closure.
Definition code
/-
APF Foundation Ledger — definition node DRAFT (session EthanBrooke-01WrrBvu, 2026-11-14; not gated, not reviewed)
name: APFB05_FreeWhereNovel
title: A candidate clause: a distinction that is new over a family takes both sides on every part marked out by the sides of that family
inputs_revision: 2026-11-14.1
revision_note: a candidate clause of pass 37, never adopted. Its condition was withdrawn on the author's
statement of 2026-11-14 02:51 HST, and the unconditioned sentence is what entered B02 at inputs revision
2026-11-14.1. Kept because APFB02.EachTakesBothSides is written with it.
mathlib_rev: 0df444a360eaa60ab8c11dca51a86af692955474
source: the author's question of 2026-11-14 02:38 HST ("Seems like the clause we add to B should be more
primitive?"). FOUNDATION_INPUTS B02 (a distinction takes both values) and B05 (support novelty), declared
forms unchanged.
standing: a CANDIDATE, typed so that it can be tested. It is not an input and not adopted. Only the author
edits the inputs.
statement: FreeWhereNovel novel reads says: whenever d is new over the family S (novel S d), then for every
state x there is a state that holds the members of S on the sides x holds them and holds d on its true side,
and another that does the same and holds d on its false side. With S empty this is B02's own clause that a
distinction takes both values.
-/
import Mathlib.Data.Finset.Insert
set_option autoImplicit false
namespace APFB05
/-- A distinction that is new over a family takes both sides whatever sides the family is held on. -/
def FreeWhereNovel {X D : Type*} (novel : Finset D → D → Prop) (reads : D → X → Bool) : Prop :=
∀ (S : Finset D) (d : D), novel S d → ∀ x : X,
(∃ y : X, (∀ e ∈ S, reads e y = reads e x) ∧ reads d y = true) ∧
(∃ z : X, (∀ e ∈ S, reads e z = reads e x) ∧ reads d z = false)
end APFB05
Source
Definitions/Def_APFB05_FreeWhereNovel.lean; Sib v52 / pullbacks v6; SHA-256 4b439f71168d5b30334875c20d5e5827ec002d0ac4c07478bdfba66a1563c6c7. Papers/Paper 01 - The Enforceability of Distinction/Paper_1_Enforceability_of_Distinction_Supplement_v9.28.tex; lines 1224-1243,1276-1332,1741-1771,1833-1885,2601-2680; APF Reference Docs/APF Reconstruction Spine/FOUNDATION_INPUTS.json; revision 2026-11-14.1; input B02; source/Definitions/Def_APFB05_FreeWhereNovel.lean
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.