Context lifting changes a skeptical consequence into a credulous one along a route
ProvedTranscendenceTower.Chaining.lifting_is_route_sensitiveFor the direct transfer from to , is a consequence under every minimal blocking set. After routing through , one minimal resolution preserves and another loses it. Thus the route changes from a skeptical consequence to a merely credulous consequence.
The proof isolates the intermediate context's contribution. The first unblocked transfer forms ; this set conflicts with the destination even though the original source does not.
- The direct source and destination are jointly satisfiable, so the empty blocking set is admissible.
- Because the empty set lies below every blocking set, every direct minimal block equals the empty set, and survives every direct minimal resolution.
- Along the routed transfer, blocking and blocking are both admissible and minimal.
- A model with only true witnesses that is not a consequence when is blocked.
- When is blocked, remains an assertion of the lifted context and hence a consequence.
Formalization note: the theorem states the skeptical-versus-credulous distinction directly instead of relying only on two exhibited blocking sets.
This is a finite propositional counterexample for the Lift operator defined here. It does not claim that every formalism of context transfer or every system of bridge rules is route-sensitive.
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerLiftConflicts set_option autoImplicit false open TranscendenceTower TranscendenceTower.ContextTheories TranscendenceTower.Lifting
theorem TranscendenceTower.Chaining.lifting_is_route_sensitive :
(∀ A : Set L0, MinBlock srcP tgtNand A →
pA ∈ Cn (Lift srcP tgtNand A))
∧ Lift srcP {qA} ∅ = srcPQ
∧ (∃ A : Set L0, MinBlock srcPQ tgtNand A
∧ pA ∉ Cn (Lift srcPQ tgtNand A))
∧ (∃ A : Set L0, MinBlock srcPQ tgtNand A
∧ pA ∈ Cn (Lift srcPQ tgtNand A)) := by sorry