Polynomial certificates for the canonical–plane birational maps
DefinitionN25_BirationalIdentitiesmazur-n25
This file is principally a certificate suite rather than a new carrier definition. It records the pullbacks of the canonical quadric and cubic under the plane parametrization, denominator and coordinate identities, homogeneous scaling laws, and the cleared reverse-substitution formulas over commutative rings and fields. These identities certify that the plane and canonical rational maps are mutually inverse on their common principal open.
Definition code
import Definitions.Def_N25_CanonicalUnitPlane
/-! Integral certificates and inverse formulas for the canonical and plane models. -/
namespace N25
section Ring
variable {k : Type*} [CommRing k]
/-- The plane relation pulls back the canonical quadric with the indicated factor. -/
theorem plane_quadric (u v : k) :
canonicalQuadric (planeX u v) (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) =
u * planeRelation u v := by
unfold canonicalQuadric planeX planeY planeZ planeW planeDenominator planeRelation
ring
/-- The plane relation pulls back the canonical cubic with the indicated factor. -/
theorem plane_cubic (u v : k) :
canonicalCubic (planeX u v) (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) =
-u^2*v*planeDenominator u v*planeRelation u v := by
unfold canonicalCubic planeX planeY planeZ planeW planeDenominator planeRelation
ring
theorem plane_denominator (u v : k) :
canonicalDenominator (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) =
v * planeDenominator u v := by
unfold canonicalDenominator planeY planeZ planeW planeDenominator
ring
theorem plane_x_certificate (u v : k) :
planeX u v = u * canonicalDenominator (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) := by
rw [plane_denominator]; unfold planeX; ring
theorem plane_v_certificate (u v : k) :
(planeX u v)^2 = v * planeZ u v *
canonicalDenominator (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) := by
rw [plane_denominator]; unfold planeX planeZ; ring
theorem reverse_y_certificate (x y z w : k) :
reverseY x y z w - y * canonicalMultiplier x y z w =
-x * canonicalQuadric x y z w - canonicalCubic x y z w := by
unfold reverseY canonicalMultiplier canonicalDenominator canonicalQuadric canonicalCubic
ring
theorem reverse_w_certificate (x y z w : k) :
reverseW x y z w - w * canonicalMultiplier x y z w =
-x * canonicalQuadric x y z w - canonicalCubic x y z w := by
unfold reverseW canonicalMultiplier canonicalDenominator canonicalQuadric canonicalCubic
ring
theorem reverse_x_certificate (x y z w : k) :
reverseX x y z w - x * canonicalMultiplier x y z w = 0 := by
unfold reverseX; ring
theorem reverse_z_certificate (x y z w : k) :
reverseZ x y z w - z * canonicalMultiplier x y z w = 0 := by
unfold reverseZ; ring
theorem canonicalQuadric_smul (t x y z w : k) :
canonicalQuadric (t*x) (t*y) (t*z) (t*w) = t^2*canonicalQuadric x y z w := by
unfold canonicalQuadric; ring
theorem plane_maps_to_canonical (u v : k) (h : planeRelation u v = 0) :
canonicalQuadric (planeX u v) (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) = 0 ∧
canonicalCubic (planeX u v) (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) = 0 := by
rw [plane_quadric, plane_cubic, h]; simp
/-- Reverse substitution over a ring, with an explicitly specified inverse of z. -/
theorem canonical_substitution_of_inverse (x y z w r : k)
(ha : canonicalDenominator y z w = 1) (hz : z*r = 1) :
let u := x
let v := x^2*r
let s := x^3*r^2
planeX u v = s*reverseX x y z w ∧
planeY u v = s*reverseY x y z w ∧
planeZ u v = s*reverseZ x y z w ∧
planeW u v = s*reverseW x y z w := by
have hd : planeDenominator x (x^2*r) = x*r*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by
unfold planeDenominator canonicalMultiplier
rw [ha]
linear_combination -(x^2+x)*hz
dsimp only
constructor
· unfold planeX reverseX
rw [hd]
ring
constructor
· unfold planeY reverseY
rw [ha]
linear_combination x^3*(z*r+1-r*(x^2+1))*hz
constructor
· unfold planeZ reverseZ
rw [hd]
linear_combination -x^3*r*canonicalMultiplier x y z w*hz
· unfold planeW reverseW
rw [ha]
linear_combination -x^4*(z*r+1+x*r)*hz
/-- The reverse substitution satisfies R without any domain assumption. -/
theorem canonical_maps_to_plane_of_inverse (x y z w r i : k)
(ha : canonicalDenominator y z w = 1) (hz : z*r = 1) (hx : x*i = 1)
(hq : canonicalQuadric x y z w = 0) (hc : canonicalCubic x y z w = 0) :
planeRelation x (x^2*r) = 0 := by
have hy := reverse_y_certificate x y z w
have hw := reverse_w_certificate x y z w
rw [hq, hc] at hy hw
have hy' : reverseY x y z w = y*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by linear_combination hy
have hw' : reverseW x y z w = w*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by linear_combination hw
have h := canonical_substitution_of_inverse x y z w r ha hz
dsimp only at h
rcases h with ⟨hX,hY,hZ,hW⟩
rw [hy'] at hY
rw [hw'] at hW
unfold reverseX at hX
unfold reverseZ at hZ
have heX : planeX x (x^2*r) = (x^3*r^2*canonicalMultiplier x y z w)*x := by rw [hX]; ring
have heY : planeY x (x^2*r) = (x^3*r^2*canonicalMultiplier x y z w)*y := by rw [hY]; ring
have heZ : planeZ x (x^2*r) = (x^3*r^2*canonicalMultiplier x y z w)*z := by rw [hZ]; ring
have heW : planeW x (x^2*r) = (x^3*r^2*canonicalMultiplier x y z w)*w := by rw [hW]; ring
have hp := plane_quadric x (x^2*r)
rw [heX,heY,heZ,heW,canonicalQuadric_smul,hq,mul_zero] at hp
calc
planeRelation x (x^2*r) = (x*i)*planeRelation x (x^2*r) := by rw [hx,one_mul]
_ = i*(x*planeRelation x (x^2*r)) := by ring
_ = 0 := by rw [← hp,mul_zero]
/-- The cubic scales by the third power of a common coordinate factor. -/
theorem canonicalCubic_smul (t x y z w : k) :
canonicalCubic (t*x) (t*y) (t*z) (t*w) = t^3*canonicalCubic x y z w := by
unfold canonicalCubic; ring
/-- Normalizing A=1 preserves both canonical equations on the plane open. -/
theorem plane_normalized_equations (u v h : k)
(hi : u*v*planeDenominator u v*h = 1) (hr : planeRelation u v = 0) :
let s := u*h
let y := s*planeY u v
let z := s*planeZ u v
let w := s*planeW u v
canonicalQuadric u y z w = 0 ∧ canonicalCubic u y z w = 0 ∧
canonicalDenominator y z w = 1 ∧
canonicalMultiplier u y z w = u^2*(planeDenominator u v)^2*h := by
have hx : (u*h)*planeX u v = u := by
unfold planeX
linear_combination u*hi
have hq := plane_quadric u v
have hc := plane_cubic u v
rw [hr,mul_zero] at hq hc
dsimp only
constructor
· conv_lhs => arg 1; rw [← hx]
rw [canonicalQuadric_smul,hq,mul_zero]
constructor
· conv_lhs => arg 1; rw [← hx]
rw [canonicalCubic_smul,hc,mul_zero]
have ha : canonicalDenominator ((u*h)*planeY u v) ((u*h)*planeZ u v)
((u*h)*planeW u v) = 1 := by
unfold canonicalDenominator planeY planeZ planeW planeDenominator at *
linear_combination hi
constructor
· exact ha
· unfold canonicalMultiplier
rw [ha]
unfold planeZ planeDenominator at *
linear_combination -u*hi
/-- Normalization of the reverse composition is the identity in every commutative ring. -/
theorem canonical_normalized_inverse (x y z w r s : k)
(ha : canonicalDenominator y z w = 1) (hz : z*r = 1)
(hq : canonicalQuadric x y z w = 0) (hc : canonicalCubic x y z w = 0)
(hs : x*(x^2*r)*planeDenominator x (x^2*r)*s = 1) :
x*s*planeY x (x^2*r) = y ∧ x*s*planeZ x (x^2*r) = z ∧
x*s*planeW x (x^2*r) = w := by
have hd : planeDenominator x (x^2*r) = x*r*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by
unfold planeDenominator canonicalMultiplier
rw [ha]
linear_combination -(x^2+x)*hz
rw [hd] at hs
have hy := reverse_y_certificate x y z w
have hw := reverse_w_certificate x y z w
rw [hq,hc] at hy hw
have hy' : reverseY x y z w = y*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by linear_combination hy
have hw' : reverseW x y z w = w*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by linear_combination hw
have h := canonical_substitution_of_inverse x y z w r ha hz
dsimp only at h
rw [hy'] at h
rw [hw'] at h
rcases h with ⟨_,hY,hZ,hW⟩
unfold reverseZ at hZ
constructor
· linear_combination x*s*hY + y*hs
constructor
· linear_combination x*s*hZ + z*hs
· linear_combination x*s*hW + w*hs
end Ring
section Field
variable {k : Type*} [Field k]
/-- The two rational functions recover the plane coordinates on their common open. -/
theorem plane_inverse (u v : k) (hu : u ≠ 0) (hv : v ≠ 0)
(hd : planeDenominator u v ≠ 0) :
planeX u v / canonicalDenominator (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v) = u ∧
(planeX u v)^2 / (planeZ u v *
canonicalDenominator (planeY u v) (planeZ u v) (planeW u v)) = v := by
rw [plane_denominator]
unfold planeX planeZ
constructor <;> field_simp [hu, hv, hd]
/-- Clearing the canonical denominators gives the four integral reverse numerators. -/
theorem canonical_substitution (x y z w : k)
(ha : canonicalDenominator y z w ≠ 0) (hz : z ≠ 0) :
let a := canonicalDenominator y z w
let u := x/a
let v := x^2/(z*a)
let s := x^3/(z^2*a^4)
planeX u v = s*reverseX x y z w ∧
planeY u v = s*reverseY x y z w ∧
planeZ u v = s*reverseZ x y z w ∧
planeW u v = s*reverseW x y z w := by
dsimp only
unfold planeX planeY planeZ planeW planeDenominator reverseX reverseY reverseZ reverseW
canonicalMultiplier
generalize canonicalDenominator y z w = a at *
constructor
· field_simp [ha, hz]
constructor
· field_simp [ha, hz]
constructor <;> field_simp [ha, hz]
/-- The reverse map is projectively the identity on the canonical complete intersection. -/
theorem canonical_inverse (x y z w : k)
(ha : canonicalDenominator y z w ≠ 0) (hz : z ≠ 0)
(hq : canonicalQuadric x y z w = 0) (hc : canonicalCubic x y z w = 0) :
let a := canonicalDenominator y z w
let u := x/a
let v := x^2/(z*a)
let t := x^3*canonicalMultiplier x y z w/(z^2*a^4)
planeX u v = t*x ∧ planeY u v = t*y ∧
planeZ u v = t*z ∧ planeW u v = t*w := by
have hy := reverse_y_certificate x y z w
have hw := reverse_w_certificate x y z w
rw [hq, hc] at hy hw
have hy' : reverseY x y z w = y*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by linear_combination hy
have hw' : reverseW x y z w = w*canonicalMultiplier x y z w := by linear_combination hw
have h := canonical_substitution x y z w ha hz
dsimp only at h ⊢
rcases h with ⟨hX, hY, hZ, hW⟩
rw [hy'] at hY
rw [hw'] at hW
unfold reverseX at hX
unfold reverseZ at hZ
constructor
· rw [hX]; ring
constructor
· rw [hY]; ring
constructor
· rw [hZ]; ring
· rw [hW]; ring
/-- A canonical point with nonzero x, z and denominator satisfies the plane relation. -/
theorem canonical_maps_to_plane (x y z w : k) (hx : x ≠ 0)
(ha : canonicalDenominator y z w ≠ 0) (hz : z ≠ 0)
(hq : canonicalQuadric x y z w = 0) (hc : canonicalCubic x y z w = 0) :
planeRelation (x/canonicalDenominator y z w)
(x^2/(z*canonicalDenominator y z w)) = 0 := by
have h := canonical_inverse x y z w ha hz hq hc
dsimp only at h
rcases h with ⟨hX, hY, hZ, hW⟩
have hp := plane_quadric (x/canonicalDenominator y z w)
(x^2/(z*canonicalDenominator y z w))
rw [hX, hY, hZ, hW, canonicalQuadric_smul, hq, mul_zero] at hp
exact (mul_eq_zero.mp hp.symm).resolve_left (div_ne_zero hx ha)
end Field
end N25
Source
B. Mazur, Modular curves and the Eisenstein ideal, Publ. IHES 47 (1977); Lean formalization of the order-25 case for this mission. Modules in the MazurProof/Keystone/Tate families are adapted from anthropics/fermats-last-theorem (Apache-2.0) via the xiangyazi24/FLT fork.