Theorem 9.6, p.120 — a universal gate set with computable entries for which fails
OpenQuantumKtSoI.Supplement.theorem_9_6complexity-theorykolmogorov-complexityp2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-bookp2o-strengthenedp2o-v1quantum-computing
There are a fixed finite universal gate set , all of whose entries are computable, and an encoding satisfying (Enc) of Definition 9.3, such that:
- for infinitely many positive integers there is with
- some gate of has no exact block over for any integer , where ;
- consequently, no constant makes hold for all strings .
Here is the measure defined by machines and descriptions whose gates come from , and blocks are those of Definition 9.4.
This shows that the reverse logarithmic comparison between gate sets can fail even for computable entries.
Formalization Note The gate set is chosen after the glue routine set. The is one constant for all .
Differences from the source:
- generalization: the glue routines are fixed once and for all by their p.24 properties → every admissible glue routine set G (hypothesis G.Admissible); descriptions, P_e and qKt are those of G; reason: the proofs use only the p.24 properties and the paper's routines are one admissible set; same as the published base items
- encoding: a finite set G′ of unitary gates with an encoding satisfying (Enc) → a finite indexed family of matrices with a natural-number name per gate (GateLib with Wf: arities ≥ 1, unitary, distinct names), and an injective encoding of the valid coded G′-machines; reason: a finite set with a fixed enumeration of its gate names, which (Enc) presupposes; G′-machines are represented as coded machines as in the base mission
- reading: (Enc): a polynomial-time parser recovers the complete finite structural description (no output format fixed) → a deterministic polynomial-time function maps every code to the standard structural record, the published encoding's layout with gate names from the fixed enumeration; reason: the record contains exactly the data Definition 9.3 lists; the paper leaves the format open
- reading: O(·) terms in the conclusion → one real constant K, chosen together with the named constant, multiplying each O-term; reason: the usual meaning of O(·) in an upper bound; the terms are at least 1, so one constant serves both
- reading: a complex number is computable if a deterministic Turing machine, given r, returns rational real and imaginary parts with error at most 2^{−r} → Mathlib's Computable for a function ℕ → ℤ × ℕ returning numerator and denominator, each part within 2^{−r}; reason: Turing computability is Mathlib's Computable; the error bound is applied to each part
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_QuantumKtSoI_qKt import Definitions.Def_QuantumKtSoI_Supplement_GDesc import Definitions.Def_QuantumKtSoI_Supplement_ExactBlock open Classical
Formal statement
namespace QuantumKtSoI.Supplement
/-- **Theorem 9.6** (Failure of gate comparison for computable entries; Myrisiotis, *Failure of Symmetry of Information for Quantum Computations*, STOC 2027 submission, held version sha256 6616571c…, pp.120–121). There are a
fixed finite universal gate set `G′`, all of whose entries are computable, and an encoding
satisfying (Enc) of Definition 9.3, such that for infinitely many positive integers `n` there is
`w_n ∈ {0,1}^{4n}` with `qKt(w_n) > 3n` and `qKt_{G′}(w_n) ≤ 2n + O(log(n+2))`. Some gate of `G′`
has no exact block over `G ∪ {T_m}` for any integer `m ≥ 2`. Consequently, no constant `B` makes
`qKt(y|x) ≤ qKt_{G′}(y|x) + B log(|x|+|y|+2) + B` hold for all strings `x, y`.
**Formalization Note** `G` is any admissible glue routine set (p.24), fixed before the gate set, as
in the base mission. A gate set is a `GateLib` with `Wf` (arities `≥ 1`, unitary gates); the
encoding is of the valid coded `G′`-machines and satisfies `EncHyp`; `qKt_{G′}` is `qKtG`. The
`O(log(n+2))` is one constant `K` for all `n`. Logarithms are base 2. -/
theorem theorem_9_6 (G : GlueRoutines) (hG : G.Admissible) :
∃ L : GateLib, L.Wf ∧ L.Universal ∧ L.ComputableEntries ∧
∃ enc : {A : GCodedMachine L // A.Valid} → List Bool, EncHyp L enc ∧
(∃ K : ℝ, ∀ N : ℕ, ∃ n ≥ N, 0 < n ∧ ∃ w : List Bool, w.length = 4 * n ∧
3 * n < qKt G w [] ∧
(qKtG L enc G w [] : ℝ) ≤ 2 * (n : ℝ) + K * Real.logb 2 ((n : ℝ) + 2)) ∧
(∃ g : L.ι, ∀ m : ℕ, 2 ≤ m → ¬ExactBlock (nativeTm m) (L.amp g)) ∧
∀ B : ℝ, ¬∀ x y : List Bool,
(qKt G y x : ℝ) ≤
qKtG L enc G y x + B * Real.logb 2 ((x.length : ℝ) + y.length + 2) + B := by sorry
end QuantumKtSoI.Supplement
Source
Myrisiotis, Failure of Symmetry of Information for Quantum Computations, STOC 2027 submission (held version, sha256 6616571c…), Theorem 9.6, pp.120–121; Definition 9.3, p.118; Definition 9.4, p.119; universal and computable, p.120