Waldschmidt 2005 (Variations), Cor. 2.13, corrected: if (Λᵢⱼ) ∈ ℒ̃²ˣ³, Λ₁₁, Λ₂₁ ∈ ℝ ∪ iℝ, and 1, Λ₁₁, Λ₂₁ and 1, Λ₂₁, Λ₂₂, Λ₂₃, Λ̄₂₂, Λ̄₂₃ are Q̄-free, then Λ₁₁Λ₂₂ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₂ or Λ₁₁Λ₂₃ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₃ ∉ ℒ̃
ProvedDiazModulus.variations_cor_2_13_correcteddiaz-modulus-leannumber-theorytranscendence
Here is the field of algebraic numbers, the set of logarithms of algebraic numbers ( with algebraic), and the -vector space spanned by and . A subspace is rational if it is spanned by vectors with algebraic coordinates.
Let be a matrix with entries in . Assume that and are each real or purely imaginary ( and ), that are linearly independent over , and that the six numbers are linearly independent over . Then at least one of
is not in .
Preamble
import Definitions.Def_DiazModulus
Formal statement
open Complex ComplexConjugate
namespace DiazModulus
theorem variations_cor_2_13_corrected (M : Matrix (Fin 2) (Fin 3) ℂ) (hM : ∀ i j, M i j ∈ LogAlgTilde)
(h₁₁ : conj (M 0 0) = M 0 0 ∨ conj (M 0 0) = -M 0 0)
(h₂₁ : conj (M 1 0) = M 1 0 ∨ conj (M 1 0) = -M 1 0)
(h1 : LinearIndependent (↥Qbar) ![1, M 0 0, M 1 0])
(h6 : LinearIndependent (↥Qbar) ![1, M 1 0, M 1 1, M 1 2, conj (M 1 1), conj (M 1 2)]) :
M 0 0 * M 1 1 - M 1 0 * M 0 1 ∉ LogAlgTilde ∨ M 0 0 * M 1 2 - M 1 0 * M 0 2 ∉ LogAlgTilde := by
sorry
end DiazModulus
Source
M. Waldschmidt, Variations on the six exponentials theorem, in Algebra and Number Theory (Hyderabad), Hindustan Book Agency, 2005, 338–355, Cor. 2.13 (p. 346; proof p. 347), with a corrected hypothesis. The printed Cor. 2.13 is false as stated: Λ₁₁ = 1, Λ₁₂ = Λ₁₃ = 0, Λ₂₁ = log 2, Λ₂₂ = Log(2 + i), Λ₂₃ = Log(3 + 2i) (principal logarithms) satisfy its hypotheses, the six numbers 1, log 2, Log(2 ± i), Log(3 ± 2i) being linearly independent over Q̄ by Baker's theorem, while Λ₁₁Λ₂₂ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₂ = Log(2 + i) and Λ₁₁Λ₂₃ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₃ = Log(3 + 2i) lie in ℒ. This node assumes instead that 1, Λ₁₁, Λ₂₁ are linearly independent over Q̄ (in place of 'Λ₂₁ ≠ 0 and Λ₁₁/Λ₂₁ transcendental'), as in M. Waldschmidt, The role of complex conjugation in transcendental number theory, 2005, Cor. 6.3; the printed hypothesis Λ₁₂, Λ₁₃ ∈ ℝ ∪ iℝ is not assumed. The printed proof applies Cor. 2.12 to the matrix with the conjugate columns (Λ̄₁ⱼ, Λ̄₂ⱼ), j = 2, 3; it needs signs on these columns when Λ₁₁ and Λ₂₁ are of different type (one real, the other purely imaginary). The proof here applies Role Cor. 6.3 to the columns (ε₂Λ̄₁ⱼ, ε₁Λ̄₂ⱼ), where Λ̄₁₁ = ε₁Λ₁₁ and Λ̄₂₁ = ε₂Λ₂₁ with ε₁, ε₂ ∈ {1, −1}. Formal proof: Diaz modulus mission, 14 November 2026 (C. Perassi).