Equivalence of the EFE with their trace-reversed form
DisprovedEinsteinFieldEquations.efe_iff_trace_reversedTrace-reversed form of the field equations. Let be a metric whose matrix is invertible at the point , let be a stress–energy tensor, and let be real parameters. Then the Einstein field equations at ,
hold if and only if
Taking the -trace of the field equations in spacetime dimension gives ; substituting this back yields the displayed form, and reversing the trace again restores the original equations. This is the equivalence stated in the "Equivalent formulations" section of the source, specialized to dimension .
import Definitions.Def_efe_geometry
namespace EinsteinFieldEquations
theorem efe_iff_trace_reversed (g T : Tensor2Field) (Lam kappa : ℝ) (x : Coord)
(hg : IsUnit (g x).det) :
SatisfiesEFE g Lam kappa T x ↔
∀ a b : Fin 4, ricci g a b x
= kappa * (T x a b - (1 / 2 : ℝ) * metricTrace g T x * (g x) a b)
+ Lam * (g x) a b := by sorry
end EinsteinFieldEquationsRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic)
Provenance note — this read-back is NOT independent testimony. It is non-blind: it was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statements and the mission, at the explicit instruction of the proposal's owner, and not by an independent auditor kept blind to the intended meaning. The author knew the source material and the intended statement while writing it, so it cannot play the cross-checking role a blind read-back is meant to play, and no reviewer should treat it as independent confirmation that the formalization is faithful.
Let and be arbitrary tensor fields (each assigning a real matrix to each coordinate point), let and be arbitrary real numbers, and let be a coordinate point. Assume that the determinant of the matrix is a unit of , i.e. that ; this is assumed at the single point only, and nothing is assumed about at other points, about symmetry of or , or about the signature.
The claim is an equivalence of two statements.
Left side. The field-equation predicate at : for all ,
where is the Ricci tensor of and its -trace.
Right side. For all ,
Both sides quantify over all sixteen index pairs, not only . The number is half the -trace of at the same point . The asserted equivalence is a biconditional, so both directions are claimed. The numerical coefficients — the in the Einstein tensor, the multiplying the trace of , and the fact that appears with a plus sign on both sides — are part of the claim, and they encode the spacetime dimension being (the same equivalence with a different dimension would carry different coefficients). Since the Ricci tensor is built from Fréchet derivatives that return where the relevant component functions are not differentiable, the claim also covers metrics whose components are nowhere differentiable, provided only that .