Token financing needs a smaller share than equity:
ProvedICOTheory.Signaling.token_share_lt_equity_sharecorporate-financeinformation-asymmetryinitial-coin-offeringssignaling
Let be the initial investment, the fixed production cost, and a venture type with . Then
Selling a share of tokens raises more than selling the same share of equity, because tokens are a claim to revenue and equity a claim to revenue net of the cost ; so token financing needs a smaller share. This is why the financing constraint is more likely to preclude separation under equity financing.
Differences from the source:
- reading: "the proceeds from selling a given share of tokens, αERj, are larger than the proceeds from selling the same share of equity, α (ERj − C)" → 0 < C (with 0 < I); reason: the premise holds for a positive share exactly when C > 0; at C = 0 the two shares are equal
- reading: the equity financing constraint ᾱE_j ≤ α ≤ 1 of (21) → C < μ / 4; reason: ERj − C > 0 is needed for selling equity to raise any money; at ERj − C ≤ 0 the paper's ᾱE_j is undefined or negative
- encoding: ERj → μ / 4; reason: R_j = ξ_j²/4 and Eξ_j² = µ_j (p. 18)
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ICOTheory_Signaling_alphaBarT import Definitions.Def_ICOTheory_Signaling_alphaBarE
Formal statement
namespace ICOTheory.Signaling
/-- **Token financing needs a smaller share than equity financing: `ᾱ^T_j < ᾱ^E_j`.**
Chod, Lyandres, *A Theory of ICOs: Diversification, Agency, and Information Asymmetry*,
SSRN 3159528 (December 14, 2019), §4, unnumbered, p. 21: "Because the proceeds from selling a
given share of tokens, `α𝔼R_j`, are larger than the proceeds from selling the same share of
equity, `α(𝔼R_j − C)`, financing the investment requires selling a larger share of the latter,
that is, `ᾱ^T_j < ᾱ^E_j`." (Used again in the proof of Corollary 1, p. 32.)
For an investment `I > 0`, a fixed cost `C > 0` and a type with `C < 𝔼R_j = μ_j/4`,
`I/(μ_j/4) < I/(μ_j/4 − C)`.
**Formalization Note.** `C > 0` is the sentence's premise (token proceeds exceed equity
proceeds); at `C = 0` the two shares are equal. `C < μ_j/4` makes the equity proceeds positive,
so that the equity financing constraint is meaningful. `𝔼R_j = μ_j/4` (p. 18). -/
theorem token_share_lt_equity_share {I C μ : ℝ} (hI : 0 < I) (hC : 0 < C) (hCμ : C < μ / 4) :
alphaBarT I μ < alphaBarE I C μ := by sorry
end ICOTheory.Signaling
Source
Chod, Lyandres, A Theory of ICOs: Diversification, Agency, and Information Asymmetry, SSRN 3159528 (December 14, 2019), §4, unnumbered, p. 21; used in the proof of Corollary 1, p. 32