Two conflicting contexts, one of which does not say how to resolve the conflict
DefinitionTranscendenceTowerLiftConflictsformalizing-contextlogicnonmonotonic-logic
Two pairs of contexts that conflict, differing in how much the target says about the conflict.
The first pair is a flat contradiction: the source asserts an atom and the target asserts its negation. The transfer plainly cannot go through untouched, and the only question is what must be given up.
The second pair is the interesting one. The source asserts two atoms and ; the target asserts only
The conflict is real, but the target is silent about which of the two to abandon. That is precisely the situation in which a preference for minimal abnormality is called upon to make a choice — and, as the accompanying theorem establishes, it cannot.
Valuations are supplied as witnesses for each way of resolving the conflict.
Definition code
/-
Two contexts that conflict, and a target that does not say how.
The first pair is a flat contradiction: the source asserts an atom and the
target asserts its negation, so the transfer cannot go through untouched.
The second pair is the interesting one. The source asserts two atoms and the
target asserts only that they are not *both* true. The conflict is real, but
the target is silent about which of the two to give up -- which is exactly the
situation in which a preference for minimal abnormality has to make a choice,
and, as the accompanying theorem shows, cannot.
Definitions only -- every theorem about these lives in a separate submission.
-/
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerLifting
set_option autoImplicit false
open TranscendenceTower TranscendenceTower.ContextTheories
namespace TranscendenceTower.Lifting
/-- Atom `0`. -/
def pA : L0 := Form.atom 0
/-- Atom `1`. -/
def qA : L0 := Form.atom 1
/-- A source asserting `p`. -/
def srcP : Set L0 := {pA}
/-- A target asserting `¬p`, contradicting the source outright. -/
def tgtNotP : Set L0 := {Form.neg pA}
/-- A valuation making every atom false. -/
def vNotP : Val := fun _ => false
/-- A source asserting both `p` and `q`. -/
def srcPQ : Set L0 := {pA, qA}
/-- A target asserting that `p` and `q` are not both true. -/
def tgtNand : Set L0 := {Form.neg (Form.conj pA qA)}
/-- `p` true, `q` false. -/
def vP : Val := fun k => k == 0
/-- `q` true, `p` false. -/
def vQ : Val := fun k => k == 1
end TranscendenceTower.Lifting
Source
Mateo Estrada, Harmless and Pointless: Consistency, rigidity, and the indeterminacy of context transfer in McCarthy's formalization of context, 7 September 2026, Section 7, the configurations of Theorems 12 and 13.