Eq. (35) (corrected: the ratio is ): the conditional as a ratio of two functionals of the state
ProvedHardyCausaloid.eq35_conditional_ratiocausaloidlinear-algebrap2o-correctedp2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-strengthenedp2o-v1probabilistic-theoriesquantum-gravity
Let be a causaloid of the experiment model , disjoint finite sets of locations with regions , a label of , and , a setting and an outcome family on , so that ; runs over all outcome families under . Then
- the family is summable in , and for every generalised preparation the family is summable;
- for every generalised preparation, with ,
Hence the ratio of (35),
is the joint probability divided by the probability of the conditioning event, i.e. under that preparation — the conditional probability of eq. (7). Both vectors are computed from the causaloid alone.
Differences from the source:
- correction: (35) p ≡ Prob(Y₁^{α₁} | Y₂^{α₂}, F₁^{α₁}, F₂^{α₂}) = r_{α₁α₂}·p / Σ_{β₂} r_{α₁β₂}·p → the ratio is condNum/condDen, the conditional Prob(Y₂ | Y₁, F₁, F₂) of eq. (7); reason: the printed left-hand side is false: with one setting at each of two locations, binary outcomes, Prob(0,0)=1/2, Prob(0,1)=1/4, Prob(1,0)=0, Prob(1,1)=1/4, Prob(Y₁=0 | Y₂=0) = 1 but the printed ratio is (1/2)/(3/4) = 2/3; the ratio with Σ over β₂ is the conditional of (7)
- generalization: labels α₁ = 1, 2, … of (Y₁, F₁); sums over the outcomes β₂ → settings and outcomes of arbitrary types, unconditional sums (tsum/HasSum), summability proved in the conclusion; reason: the paper does not say the label sets are finite; finite label sets are the special case, where every tsum is a finite sum
- generalization: the causaloid built in §4.2–§4.4 from chosen fiducial sets → every causaloid C of M (any fiducial sets, any Λ matrices with IsCausaloidOf C M); reason: the conclusion holds for each of them, in particular for the one the paper builds
- reading: 'any pair of regions' (p.16), 'two disjoint regions' (p.12) → two disjoint finite sets O₁, O₂ of locations, regions R_{O₁}, R_{O₂}; reason: by (2) a region is a union of elementary regions R_x; §4.3 takes the regions disjoint
- encoding: a generalised preparation (Y_{R−R₁−R₂}, F_{R−R₁−R₂}) in R − R₁ − R₂ → a total label s whose values on the region are ignored (it enters only through glue); reason: the labels of R off the region are exactly the generalised preparations; same instances
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_HardyCausaloid_Model import Definitions.Def_HardyCausaloid_Region import Definitions.Def_HardyCausaloid_Fiducial import Definitions.Def_HardyCausaloid_Causaloid import Definitions.Def_HardyCausaloid_Conditional set_option autoImplicit false
Formal statement
namespace HardyCausaloid
/-- **Eq. (35), corrected: the conditional probability as a ratio of two linear functionals of
the state**, Hardy, arXiv:gr-qc/0608043v1, §4.5, eq. (35), p.16 ("where β2 runs over all
outcomes for the measurement associated with α2 (recall that α2 labels a particular outcome of
a particular measurement)").
Let `C` be a causaloid of the model `M`, `O₁`, `O₂` disjoint finite sets of locations, `α₁` a
label of `R₁`, and `F₂`, `Y₂` a setting and an outcome family on `O₂`; `β₂` runs over all
outcome families under `F₂`. Then
1. the family `β₂ ↦ r_{α₁β₂}(R₁ ∪ R₂)` is summable in `ℝ^{Ω₁₂}`, and for every generalised
preparation `s` the family of probabilities `β₂ ↦ p_{α₁β₂}(s)` is summable;
2. for every `s`, the joint probability is `r_{α₁α₂}(R₁ ∪ R₂) · p(R₁ ∪ R₂)` and the probability
of the conditioning event is `(Σ_{β₂} r_{α₁β₂}(R₁ ∪ R₂)) · p(R₁ ∪ R₂)`.
So the ratio of (35) is `condNum s / condDen s`, which is `Prob(Y₂ | Y₁, F₁, F₂)` under the
preparation `s`, the probability of eq. (7) (p.10).
**Formalization Note** The printed left-hand side of (35), `Prob(Y₁ | Y₂, F₁, F₂)`, is not the
ratio (correction C1); Lean has no `Prob` symbol, and the conditional is the pair
`condNum`/`condDen`. -/
theorem eq35_conditional_ratio {X : Type*} {Setting : X → Type*}
{Outcome : (x : X) → Setting x → Type*} [DecidableEq X] (M : Model Setting Outcome)
(C : Causaloid Setting Outcome) (hC : IsCausaloidOf C M)
{O₁ O₂ : Finset X} (hO : Disjoint O₁ O₂) (α₁ : Lab Setting Outcome O₁)
(F₂ : ∀ x : O₂, Setting x.1) (Y₂ : ∀ x : O₂, Outcome x.1 (F₂ x)) :
Summable (fun β₂ : (∀ x : O₂, Outcome x.1 (F₂ x)) =>
C.r (O₁ ∪ O₂) (joinLab α₁ (labOf F₂ β₂))) ∧
(∀ s, Summable (fun β₂ : (∀ x : O₂, Outcome x.1 (F₂ x)) =>
regionTable M (O₁ ∪ O₂) (joinLab α₁ (labOf F₂ β₂)) s)) ∧
(∀ s, condNum M α₁ F₂ Y₂ s = condA C α₁ F₂ Y₂ ⬝ᵥ C.state M (O₁ ∪ O₂) s) ∧
(∀ s, condDen M α₁ F₂ s = condB C α₁ F₂ ⬝ᵥ C.state M (O₁ ∪ O₂) s) := by sorry
end HardyCausaloid
Source
Hardy, Towards Quantum Gravity: A Framework for Probabilistic Theories with Non-Fixed Causal Structure, arXiv:gr-qc/0608043v1, §4.5, eq. (35), p.16
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.