Proposition 7, p. 21 — without quality commitment in the direct channel, quality differentiation across channels is always optimal
ProvedQualityEncroach.NoCommit.proposition_7Consider the supply chain of §6.3: consumers with quality sensitivity uniform on , unit cost for quality (), direct selling cost , and the timing (i) the manufacturer announces the retailer's quality and the wholesale price ; (ii) the retailer orders ; (iii) the manufacturer chooses the direct-channel quality and quantity . Because is chosen after the retailer's order, the manufacturer cannot commit to the quality of the direct-channel product.
Let be a subgame perfect equilibrium of this game, and suppose that on the equilibrium path the manufacturer encroaches () and the retailer orders (). Then the two channels carry products of different quality:
The paper states this as: if the encroaching manufacturer cannot commit to a level of quality in the direct-channel product, then quality differentiation across channels is always optimal. It contrasts with Proposition 4 of the same paper, where under commitment uniform quality can be optimal.
Formalization Note. "Across channels" is read as both channels selling, hence the hypothesis on the path; the paper's proof also needs it (see the stage-3 item). The statement concerns every subgame perfect equilibrium; the paper does not prove that one exists, and neither does this statement.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_QualityEncroach_NoCommit_Game
namespace QualityEncroach.NoCommit
/-- **Proposition 7** (p. 21). If the encroaching manufacturer cannot commit to the quality of
the direct-channel product, then in every subgame perfect equilibrium in which she encroaches
(`q_M > 0`) and the retailer orders (`q_R > 0`), the two channels carry different qualities. -/
theorem proposition_7 (k c : ℝ) (hk : 0 < k) (hc : 0 ≤ c) (σ : Profile) (hσ : IsSPE k c σ)
(henc : Encroaches σ) (hR : 0 < σ.path.qR) :
σ.path.uM ≠ σ.path.uR := by sorry
end QualityEncroach.NoCommit
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.