Section 3 — primary decompositions and the printed counterexample
DefinitionPhilipponMultiplicity_SectionThreeSupportActual finite minimal primary decompositions, dimension slices, relevance and component selections; fixed coordinate ideals and nilpotent witness from the printed counterexample. The witness-square identity and membership are proved without admissions.
Compiled, admission-free definition bundle. Theorems asserting its substantive properties remain open targets in the full-paper goal.
import Definitions.Def_PhilipponMultiplicity_SectionThree
/-! Actual primary components and concrete algebra used in section three.
No degree estimates or conclusions of Facts A–E are fields of these data. -/
set_option autoImplicit false
open scoped BigOperators
noncomputable section
namespace PhilipponMultiplicity.SectionThreeSupport
open SectionThree
universe u
variable {K : Type u} [Field K]
/-- The reduced cone supported on the relevant minimal primes. Removing
irrelevant components is necessary before comparing affine and projective
dimensions in a multigraded coordinate ring. -/
def relevantRadicalCore (M : MultiProjectiveSpace K) (I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing) :
Ideal M.CoordinateRing := by
classical
exact ⨅ q : Hilbert.MinimalComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension I,
if Hilbert.IsRelevant K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension q.1.asIdeal then
q.1.asIdeal else ⊤
/-- The literal expansion from equation (*) on p. 362. -/
def degreeCoefficientSum (M : MultiProjectiveSpace K) (I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing)
(d : M.FactorIndex → ℕ) : ℚ :=
∑ α : BoundedMultiIndex M,
idealMixedDegree M I (fun i => (α i).val) * (idealDimension M I).factorial /
(∏ i, ((α i).val.factorial : ℚ)) * ∏ i, (d i : ℚ) ^ (α i).val
/-- A genuine finite minimal homogeneous primary decomposition. The
intersection, primary properties, irredundancy, and distinct radicals are
the standard definition of such a decomposition, not a multiplicity bound. -/
structure PrimaryDecomposition (M : MultiProjectiveSpace K) (I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing) where
count : ℕ
component : Fin count → Ideal M.CoordinateRing
primary : ∀ i, (component i).IsPrimary
homogeneous : ∀ i, IsMultihomogeneousIdeal M (component i)
intersection_eq : I = ⨅ i, component i
irredundant : ∀ i : Fin count, (⨅ j : {j : Fin count // j ≠ i}, component j.1) ≠ I
radicals_injective : Function.Injective (fun i => (component i).radical)
def PrimaryDecomposition.IsIsolated {M : MultiProjectiveSpace K}
{I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing} (D : PrimaryDecomposition M I) (i : Fin D.count) : Prop :=
(D.component i).radical ∈ I.minimalPrimes
def PrimaryDecomposition.IsEmbedded {M : MultiProjectiveSpace K}
{I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing} (D : PrimaryDecomposition M I) (i : Fin D.count) : Prop :=
¬ D.IsIsolated i
def PrimaryDecomposition.isolatedIntersection {M : MultiProjectiveSpace K}
{I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing} (D : PrimaryDecomposition M I) : Ideal M.CoordinateRing := by
classical
exact ⨅ i, if D.IsIsolated i then D.component i else ⊤
def PrimaryDecomposition.embeddedIntersection {M : MultiProjectiveSpace K}
{I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing} (D : PrimaryDecomposition M I) : Ideal M.CoordinateRing := by
classical
exact ⨅ i, if D.IsEmbedded i then D.component i else ⊤
/-- Source J(b): isolated, relevant primary components of dimension b. -/
def dimensionSlice (M : MultiProjectiveSpace K) (I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing) (b : ℕ) :
Ideal M.CoordinateRing := by
classical
exact ⨅ q : Hilbert.MinimalComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension I,
if Hilbert.IsRelevant K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension q.1.asIdeal ∧
idealDimension M q.1.asIdeal = b then
Hilbert.primaryComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension I q.1 else ⊤
/-- Source J(≥b), with the empty intersection equal to the whole ring. -/
def dimensionAtLeast (M : MultiProjectiveSpace K) (I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing) (b : ℕ) :
Ideal M.CoordinateRing := by
classical
exact ⨅ q : Hilbert.MinimalComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension I,
if Hilbert.IsRelevant K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension q.1.asIdeal ∧
b ≤ idealDimension M q.1.asIdeal then
Hilbert.primaryComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension I q.1 else ⊤
/-- Source N₁: isolated components of J whose primes are not associated to I. -/
def discardedPart (M : MultiProjectiveSpace K) (J I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing) :
Ideal M.CoordinateRing := by
classical
exact ⨅ q : Hilbert.MinimalComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension J,
if q.1.asIdeal ∉ associatedPrimes M.CoordinateRing (M.CoordinateRing ⧸ I) then
Hilbert.primaryComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension J q.1 else ⊤
/-- Source N₂: the complementary isolated components of J. -/
def retainedPart (M : MultiProjectiveSpace K) (J I : Ideal M.CoordinateRing) :
Ideal M.CoordinateRing := by
classical
exact ⨅ q : Hilbert.MinimalComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension J,
if q.1.asIdeal ∈ associatedPrimes M.CoordinateRing (M.CoordinateRing ⧸ I) then
Hilbert.primaryComponent K M.factorCount M.ambientDimension J q.1 else ⊤
namespace BezoutBoundary
def ambient : MultiProjectiveSpace ℂ := projectiveSpace ℂ 4
def X (j : Fin 5) : ambient.CoordinateRing :=
MvPolynomial.X ⟨(0 : Fin 1), j⟩
def firstGenerator : ambient.CoordinateRing := X 1 ^ 2 * X 3 - X 2 ^ 2 * X 0
def secondGenerator : ambient.CoordinateRing := X 1 * X 4 - X 2 * X 3
def thirdGenerator : ambient.CoordinateRing := X 3 ^ 3 - X 4 ^ 2 * X 0
/-- The three generators printed on p. 370, without the false primality claim. -/
def initialIdeal : Ideal ambient.CoordinateRing :=
Ideal.span {firstGenerator, secondGenerator, thirdGenerator}
def firstEquation : ambient.CoordinateRing := X 3
def secondEquation : ambient.CoordinateRing := X 1 - X 4
def sectionIdeal : Ideal ambient.CoordinateRing :=
initialIdeal ⊔ Ideal.span {firstEquation, secondEquation}
def reducedSectionGenerators : Ideal ambient.CoordinateRing :=
Ideal.span {X 1 ^ 2, X 2 ^ 2 * X 0, X 3, X 1 - X 4}
def firstComponent : Ideal ambient.CoordinateRing :=
Ideal.span {X 1 ^ 2, X 2 ^ 2, X 3, X 1 - X 4}
def secondComponent : Ideal ambient.CoordinateRing :=
Ideal.span {X 0, X 1 ^ 2, X 3, X 1 - X 4}
/-- This explicit cubic is outside the printed ideal, but its square is in it. -/
def nonradicalWitness : ambient.CoordinateRing :=
X 1 * X 3 ^ 2 - X 2 * X 4 * X 0
theorem witness_sq_identity : nonradicalWitness ^ 2 =
firstGenerator * thirdGenerator + X 0 * X 3 * secondGenerator ^ 2 := by
dsimp [nonradicalWitness, firstGenerator, secondGenerator, thirdGenerator]
ring
theorem witness_sq_mem_initialIdeal : nonradicalWitness ^ 2 ∈ initialIdeal := by
have hf2 : secondGenerator ∈ initialIdeal := by
apply Ideal.subset_span
simp
have hf3 : thirdGenerator ∈ initialIdeal := by
apply Ideal.subset_span
simp
have hs : secondGenerator ^ 2 ∈ initialIdeal := by
simpa [pow_two] using initialIdeal.mul_mem_left secondGenerator hf2
rw [witness_sq_identity]
exact initialIdeal.add_mem (initialIdeal.mul_mem_left firstGenerator hf3)
(initialIdeal.mul_mem_left (X 0 * X 3) hs)
/-- Candidate to be identified with the actual eventual Hilbert polynomial. -/
def expectedInitialHilbertPolynomial : MvPolynomial (Fin 1) ℚ :=
2 * MvPolynomial.X 0 ^ 2 + 3 * MvPolynomial.X 0 + 1
end BezoutBoundary
end PhilipponMultiplicity.SectionThreeSupport
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · gpt-6
For any field and any multiprojective space as follows, this bundle defines ideals and numerical expressions and two explicit polynomial identities. A multiprojective space means a product with a positive natural number and natural numbers , with coordinate ring . Evaluation uses the chosen nonzero representative of each projective point; a polynomial has multidegree when every monomial in its support has degree in block , so the zero polynomial has every multidegree. Its Zariski topology is generated by nonvanishing sets of such homogeneous polynomials, and denotes the ideal spanned by the homogeneous polynomials vanishing on . For every ideal , let be the chosen polynomial, if one exists, whose value at every coordinatewise sufficiently large is the -dimension of the image of the multidegree- homogeneous polynomial space in ; set if no such polynomial exists. Put , with when , , and when , with otherwise; is its total-homogeneous component of that degree. Let , , let be the prime ideals minimal over , call relevant when , and set . The relevant radical core of is . The coefficient sum at is . A primary decomposition datum of is a natural number and ideals , each primary and stable under every multihomogeneous-component projection, satisfying , such that deleting any one changes this intersection and the radicals are pairwise distinct. Its component is isolated exactly when and embedded exactly when it is not isolated; its isolated and embedded intersections intersect the respective components. For , the dimension- slice is over relevant with , and the dimension-at-least- ideal is the same intersection with . For arbitrary ideals , their discarded part is over not in , and their retained part intersects the complementary minimal primes that do belong to ; these last two definitions do not impose relevance. Every empty intersection is the unit ideal, so a zero-component primary decomposition is permitted exactly for the unit ideal and its other conditions are then vacuous; and are permitted, factorial denominators remain nonzero, and . The concrete boundary definitions use , , , and in : , , , , the two equations are and , and . The reduced-section-generators ideal is , the first component is , the second is , and the witness is . The two theorem declarations assert and , respectively; they do not assert . The expected initial Hilbert polynomial is defined to be the polynomial , without this definition asserting that it equals .