Plastic metric spaces and plastic unit balls
DefinitionPlasticity_BasicA metric space is plastic if every nonexpansive bijection (that is, for all ) is an isometry. For a normed space (only its norm matters, so any normed abelian group will do), we say that has a plastic unit ball if the closed unit ball , with the metric induced by the norm, is plastic. The plasticity problem asks whether the unit ball of every real Banach space is plastic.
Formalization Note IsPlasticSpace M is plasticity of a metric space; HasPlasticUnitBall E is IsPlasticSpace of the subtype Metric.closedBall (0 : E) 1 and assumes only [NormedAddCommGroup E], with no scalar structure and no completeness.
import Mathlib.Analysis.Normed.Module.Basic import Mathlib.Topology.MetricSpace.Isometry import Mathlib.Topology.EMetricSpace.Lipschitz /-! # Plasticity: basic notions A metric space is *plastic* if every nonexpansive (1-Lipschitz) bijection of it onto itself is an isometry. The plasticity problem asks whether the closed unit ball of every real Banach space is plastic; the definitions below assume no completeness. -/ namespace Plasticity /-- A metric space `M` is plastic if every 1-Lipschitz bijection `M → M` is an isometry. -/ def IsPlasticSpace (M : Type*) [MetricSpace M] : Prop := ∀ f : M → M, LipschitzWith 1 f → Function.Bijective f → Isometry f /-- `E` has a plastic unit ball: the closed unit ball of `E`, with the metric induced by the norm, is a plastic metric space. -/ def HasPlasticUnitBall (E : Type*) [NormedAddCommGroup E] : Prop := IsPlasticSpace (Metric.closedBall (0 : E) 1) end Plasticity
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5-5
The file imports only Mathlib (normed groups and modules, isometries, Lipschitz maps) and makes two definitions in the namespace Plasticity, each a proposition (a Prop), with no axioms, no sorry, and no further hypotheses.
Plasticity.IsPlasticSpace.
The argument is a type in an arbitrary universe, equipped with a metric-space structure (a genuine metric: forces ; no completeness, compactness, boundedness or nonemptiness is assumed).
The proposition says: for every function (no continuity or other regularity assumed beyond what follows), if
(nonexpansive, with non-strict inequality; Mathlib states this through the extended distance, which here is the same as because is finite) and is bijective (injective and surjective, with nothing assumed about the inverse), then is an isometry:
Nothing about linearity, affinity or fixed points is required or concluded; only distance preservation for all pairs. Edge cases: if is empty, the only map is the empty map, which is an isometry, so the empty space satisfies the definition vacuously; a one-point space satisfies it trivially.
Plasticity.HasPlasticUnitBall.
The argument is a type in an arbitrary universe with the structure of a normed additive commutative group: an abelian group with a norm satisfying , and , and with metric .
No scalar field, no vector-space or normed-space structure (over or anything else), no homogeneity , and no completeness is required.
The proposition says that the set
(the closed ball of radius exactly about , i.e. points at distance from ; not the open ball and not the sphere), viewed as a metric space with the restricted metric , satisfies IsPlasticSpace as unfolded above.
In full: every map that is a bijection of onto itself and satisfies for all also satisfies for all .
Edge cases: always contains , so it is never empty; if then and the property holds trivially.
When happens to be a real normed space, is its usual closed unit ball with the norm metric; for a complex normed space only the metric matters, so the property is the same as for the underlying real space.
Flags.
HasPlasticUnitBallasks only for a normed abelian group, not a real normed (or Banach) space, although its name, the comment "closed unit ball of ", and the module comment ("closed unit ball of every real Banach space") suggest a vector space. The definition therefore also applies to, e.g., with (where ) or any abelian group with the norm for (where is the whole group with the discrete metric, on which every bijection is an isometry). For real normed spaces it agrees with the usual notion; any downstream statement that should concern real normed or Banach spaces must add those hypotheses itself.- No completeness is assumed in either definition; the module comment states this explicitly.
IsPlasticSpaceholds vacuously for the empty space; this cannot affectHasPlasticUnitBall, whose ball always contains .- Neither definition is vacuous or trivially true in general: the hypotheses (1-Lipschitz and bijective) are satisfiable by the identity map on any space, and the conclusion is the full pairwise equality of distances.