Theorem 2, p. 13 — a usage-driven business under-collects and under-protects; with P > 0 it never under-collects while over-protecting
ProvedDigitalPrivacy.Welfare.theorem_2Work in the model of DigitalPrivacy.Welfare.Setting under the standing assumptions , , , , . Let be any business optimum, a feasible maximizer of the profit , and let be any social optimum, a feasible maximizer of (problem (7)). Then:
- if the business is purely usage-driven (), it under-collects and under-protects users' data:
- if the business's revenue has a data-driven component (), it never under-collects and over-protects: it is not the case that
with at least one of the two inequalities strict.
These are the first two sentences of Theorem 2. They identify the one direction of misalignment between a monopolist's data strategy and the socially optimal one that no revenue model produces, and show that a purely usage-driven business errs on the side of too little data protection.
Formalization Note. The statement holds for every pair of optima; neither existence nor uniqueness is asserted. Two hypotheses are added to the printed ranges: (with , , both optima are for any and part 1 fails) and (with the planner's problem is the business's and the paper's argument does not apply). The third sentence of Theorem 2 ("any other direction … is the outcome for some specification") is established numerically in the paper and is not part of this statement.
Retired 2026-10-27: a Lean-vs-paper fidelity audit found this statement weaker than, or narrower than, the cited result. A corrected statement will be resubmitted.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_DigitalPrivacy_Welfare_Setting
namespace DigitalPrivacy.Welfare
theorem theorem_2 (β ρ ψ P α : ℝ) (h : Standing β ρ ψ P α) (ξs Cs ξW CW : ℝ)
(hs : DigitalPrivacy.Strategy.IsBusinessOpt β ρ ψ P ξs Cs) (hW : IsSocialOpt β ρ ψ P α ξW CW) :
(P = 0 → ξs ≤ ξW ∧ Cs ≤ CW) ∧
(0 < P → ¬ (ξs ≤ ξW ∧ CW ≤ Cs ∧ (ξs < ξW ∨ CW < Cs))) := by sorry
end DigitalPrivacy.Welfare
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.