The one-prime difference operator is not bounded below on
ProvedMasulloAudit.prime_difference_not_bounded_belowSetting. Fix a real number and let be the measure on . The space carries the norm
This is the Sobolev norm (9.1.2.3) of the manuscript, , for functions of the module alone, written in the coordinate . For it is the norm of on the functions invariant under (the trivial -isotype). In this coordinate the one-prime operator of the proof of Proposition 11.2.0.1 is the difference operator
The statement below allows either sign of , so it does not depend on the sign convention for the translation.
Statement. For every real , every real and every there is a function such that
The strict inequality forces . Hence is not bounded below on : there is no constant with for all . The witness used in the proof is the indicator with large, for which .
Bearing on the manuscript. Proposition 11.2.0.1(2) and the paragraph before it (p. 484) assert that, for , the extension by continuity of to the Hardy–Sobolev completion "remains a linear topological embedding with closed range". A linear topological embedding of normed spaces is bounded below. For a single finite place (, so is allowed) and the trivial -isotype over , the present theorem shows that the operator is not bounded below, for every . This refutes the "topological embedding" part of the printed assertion in this model. The formal statement here does not include injectivity of or the non-closedness of its range; those are separate statements (an injective bounded operator between Banach spaces has closed range if and only if it is bounded below). This is an audit fact about one printed proposition, not a statement about the Riemann Hypothesis.
import Mathlib set_option autoImplicit false open MeasureTheory
theorem MasulloAudit.prime_difference_not_bounded_below (s ℓ c : ℝ) (hs : 0 ≤ s) (hℓ : ℓ ≠ 0) (hc : 0 < c) :
∃ f : ℝ → ℂ,
MemLp f 2 (volume.withDensity fun u : ℝ => ENNReal.ofReal ((1 + u ^ 2) ^ (s / 2))) ∧
eLpNorm (fun u => f u - f (u - ℓ)) 2
(volume.withDensity fun u : ℝ => ENNReal.ofReal ((1 + u ^ 2) ^ (s / 2))) <
ENNReal.ofReal c *
eLpNorm f 2 (volume.withDensity fun u : ℝ => ENNReal.ofReal ((1 + u ^ 2) ^ (s / 2))) := by sorry