Proof of Theorem 12, p. 1898 — sharper form: for parameters in PAR the coagulation and fragmentation joint laws agree iff (64)
ProvedLambdaCoalescent.CoagFrag.theorem_12_sharpLet and let , , , lie in PAR. Consider the joint law of defined by
- is an partition and is an -coagulation of ,
and the joint law of defined instead by
- is an partition and is an -fragmentation of .
These two joint laws are identical if and only if the parameters are of the form allowed in Theorem 12, that is
The "if" direction is Theorem 12 with ; the "only if" direction shows that the parameters of Theorem 12 are the only ones within the two-parameter family for which the coagulation of an partition is undone by a fragmentation.
Formalization Note The left side quantifies over all probability laws on with EPFs , , , (they exist by Lemma 9, so the quantifier is not vacuous) and states equality of the two joint laws exactly as in Theorem 12. In (64) the relation is written multiplicatively, , so that no division by occurs when (allowed by PAR); for the two forms coincide, and for the page's is undefined. EPFs are in the cancelled form of the Setting module.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_LambdaCoalescent_CoagFrag_Setting
namespace LambdaCoalescent.CoagFrag
open MeasureTheory
theorem theorem_12_sharp (α θ αc θc α₁ θ₁ αf θf : ℝ)
(hα0 : 0 ≤ α) (hα1 : α < 1) (hθ : -α < θ)
(hαc0 : 0 ≤ αc) (hαc1 : αc < 1) (hθc : -αc < θc)
(hα₁0 : 0 ≤ α₁) (hα₁1 : α₁ < 1) (hθ₁ : -α₁ < θ₁)
(hαf0 : 0 ≤ αf) (hαf1 : αf < 1) (hθf : -αf < θf) :
(∀ (μ ν ρ κ : Measure LambdaCoalescent.Rates.PInf) [IsProbabilityMeasure μ] [IsProbabilityMeasure ν]
[IsProbabilityMeasure ρ] [IsProbabilityMeasure κ],
IsEPFLaw (pdEPF α θ) μ → IsEPFLaw (pdEPF αc θc) ν →
IsEPFLaw (pdEPF α₁ θ₁) ρ → IsEPFLaw (pdEPF αf θf) κ →
∀ S : Set (LambdaCoalescent.Rates.PInf × LambdaCoalescent.Rates.PInf), MeasurableSet S →
(μ.prod ν) {x | (x.1, coag x.1 x.2) ∈ S} =
(ρ.prod (Measure.infinitePi (fun _ : ℕ => κ))) {y | (frag y.1 y.2, y.1) ∈ S}) ↔
(αf = α ∧ θf = -α₁ ∧ α₁ = α * αc ∧ α * θc = θ ∧ θ₁ = θ) := by sorry
end LambdaCoalescent.CoagFrag
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.