Theorem 2, first direction, p. 7627 — if ρ(E)+ρ(Eᶜ) < 1, monotonicity in optimal mixtures fails on {E,Eᶜ}-measurable acts
ProvedSurelyBetter.CLB.theorem2_violationLet be a finite set of states and let be a convex set containing two distinct points; stands for , the range of a nonconstant affine utility on simple lotteries. Acts are represented by their utility profiles (see the definitions item for why this is exact). Let be a c-linearly biseparable preference with capacity : is normalized, monotone and continuous on , and for every event the functional , , represents on all binary acts. Fix an event and write for its complement.
If
then violates monotonicity in optimal mixtures restricted to acts measurable with respect to : there are such acts (statewise) and for which the set of optimal weights on in is not smaller in the set order than the set of optimal weights on in .
This is the incompatibility half of Theorem 2: ambiguity aversion toward a single event already rules out monotone comparative statics of optimal mixtures, for every c-linearly biseparable preference (MEU, Choquet EU, -MEU).
Formalization Note Acts are utility profiles S → ℝ with values in U; the hypotheses Convex ℝ U and ∃ a ∈ U, ∃ b ∈ U, a ≠ b encode that for a nonconstant affine , and IsCLinBisep U V ρ bundles the standing MBA restriction of §4 with the representation (7) as an order equivalence over binary acts of all events.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_Supermodularity_Lattices_InducedSetOrder import Definitions.Def_SurelyBetter_CLB_Model
namespace SurelyBetter.CLB
theorem theorem2_violation {S : Type*} [Fintype S] (U : Set ℝ) (hU : Convex ℝ U)
(hU2 : ∃ a ∈ U, ∃ b ∈ U, a ≠ b) (V : (S → ℝ) → ℝ) (ρ : Set S → ℝ)
(hV : IsCLinBisep U V ρ) (E : Set S) :
ρ E + ρ Eᶜ < 1 → ¬ MOMOn V (measE U E) := by sorry
end SurelyBetter.CLB
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.