Proposition 3, p. 19 — for piecewise-linear concave utility and support ℝⁿ, a worst-case distribution over D₁(ℝⁿ, µ̂, Σ̂, γ₁, γ₂) has E[(ξ−µ̂)(ξ−µ̂)ᵀ] = γ₂Σ̂
ProvedMomentDRO.WorstCov.proposition_3Let assets have random return vector and let be a portfolio. Let the utility be piecewise linear concave, with , so that the cost is . Let , , and , and consider the inner problem of the robust portfolio problem (16) with unconstrained support,
Then (18) attains its maximum at a distribution whose covariance constraint is tight: there is with
That is, the covariance constraint (1b), , holds with equality at a worst-case distribution (for the mean is and this matrix is the covariance of ): the worst-case distribution has the largest covariance the set allows, and a lower bound on the covariance would not change the robust portfolio problem.
Formalization Note The proposition is worded for "the robust portfolio optimization problem", i.e. problem (16) with (§5.1, Theorem 4); its proof writes out only the case ("for simplicity of our derivations", the inner problem (18)). The statement covers every , as the proposition does; is Assumption 3's. "Infinite support constraint" is . The portfolio ranges over all of : the simplex constraint (16b) is not used by the inner problem, so dropping it makes the statement stronger. is Assumption 3's (also endnote 1, p. 22); is §3's. The conclusion asserts that one maximizer is tight, not that every maximizer is (for every member of is a maximizer).
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_MomentDRO_WorstCov_Setting open MeasureTheory Matrix
namespace MomentDRO.WorstCov
theorem proposition_3 {n K : ℕ} [NeZero K] (a b : Fin K → ℝ) (x : Fin n → ℝ)
(μhat : Fin n → ℝ) (Sighat : Matrix (Fin n) (Fin n) ℝ) (hSig : Sighat.PosDef)
(γ1 γ2 : ℝ) (hγ1 : 0 ≤ γ1) (hγ2 : 0 < γ2) :
∃ P ∈ D1 Set.univ μhat Sighat γ1 γ2,
MomentDRO.Conf.secondMomentAbout P μhat = γ2 • Sighat ∧
∀ Q ∈ D1 Set.univ μhat Sighat γ1 γ2,
∫ ξ, pwCost a b x ξ ∂Q ≤ ∫ ξ, pwCost a b x ξ ∂P := by sorry
end MomentDRO.WorstCov
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.