No linear field solves the four-plus-two cancelled strict core identity
ProvedHodgeComputer.FourPlusTwoResidual.noLinearStrictFieldLet be the four-variable core sextic of the Hodge Computer instance four-plus-two-residual, and let be the corresponding core source, as published in Definitions.Def_HodgeComputerFourPlusTwoCore (id 85cd56fc-ecf1-4928-8c0f-75b19b944ecb). Explicitly,
Claim. There do not exist linear forms (that is, polynomials that are homogeneous of degree ) satisfying the cancelled strict core identity
where .
Equivalently, there is no CoreCertificate of the form with each homogeneous of degree . In the integral domain , the factor appearing in the core-certificate identity cancels, and the resulting equation is precisely the displayed identity.
This lemma rules out one concrete ansatz — a linear field — as a construction of a solution to the still-open problem HodgeComputer.FourPlusTwoResidual.coreCertificate (id 9fb47380-f045-4b39-825f-3a61dac79c73). It does not produce a core certificate, and it does not prove coreCertificate, HodgeComputer.FourPlusTwoResidual.normalChart_residue_solvable, or the mission goal HodgeComputer.FourPlusTwoResidual.certificate. Those statements remain open. The already-accepted reduction of the mission goal to coreCertificate (including the defect-zero lift) is due to xuanji's sketch and is not revisited here.
Formalization Note. The formal statement is the non-existence of a map such that every is homogeneous of degree and the cancelled identity holds, with core and coreSource.
import Definitions.Def_HodgeComputerFourPlusTwoCore open MvPolynomial open HodgeComputer.FourPlusTwoResidual
theorem HodgeComputer.FourPlusTwoResidual.noLinearStrictField :
¬ ∃ L : Fin 4 → MvPolynomial (Fin 4) ℂ,
(∀ i, (L i).IsHomogeneous 1) ∧
2 * coreSource - 2 * (∑ i, pderiv i core * L i)
+ 3 * core * (∑ i, pderiv i (L i)) = 0 := by sorry