Theorem 7, p. 502 — Π*_SSI − Π*_DS is increasing in the cost heterogeneity Δ_c
ProvedMitigateSupplyRisk.Heterogeneity.theorem_7Consider two suppliers that are identical in every attribute (revenue , salvage , penalty , committed cost , capacity , capacity-loss distributions , initial reliability , success probability , effort cost , effort function ) except in unit cost, with
Let be the optimal expected profit of single sourcing with improvement under early commitment (the firm picks one supplier, invests in improving it, and orders only from it), and the optimal expected profit of dual sourcing without improvement, both computed at these costs. Then
Both strategies benefit from the cheaper supplier (Theorem 6), but dual sourcing is held back by the more expensive one, so single sourcing with improvement becomes increasingly preferred as the suppliers' costs diverge. The paper observes this in its numerical study (Figure 4(a)) and confirms it with this theorem.
Formalization Note "Increasing" is in the weak sense (p. 492). Both values are optimal values of the model, recomputed at each : suprema over all order quantities , all target indices , and both choices of the single source. The standing assumptions of the model, including the disclosed readings , and , are the fields of SymData.Standing. No restriction and no concavity of in is assumed; the paper states the theorem without them.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_MitigateSupplyRisk_Heterogeneity_Model
namespace MitigateSupplyRisk.Heterogeneity
theorem theorem_7 (S : SymData) (hS : S.Standing) :
MonotoneOn (fun Δ => (S.costModel Δ).PiSSI - (S.costModel Δ).PiDS) (Set.Ico 0 S.c) := by sorry
end MitigateSupplyRisk.Heterogeneity
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.