Proposition 5, p. 13 — for concave inverse demand, 1 ≤ Π**/Π* ≤ 2 and 1 ≤ P**/P* ≤ 2 for the linear price P* = (P_m + c)/2
ProvedLinearPriceRule.Concave.proposition_5Consider a monopoly with maximum price , marginal cost , saturation quantity , and an inverse demand with that is non-increasing, continuous and concave on . Let be the linear price, the profit of charging it, where is the largest quantity in with . Then a profit-maximizing quantity exists, , and every profit-maximizing quantity , with optimal price and optimal profit , satisfies
The linear pricing rule needs only and . For every concave inverse demand it earns at least half of the optimal profit, and the factor is attained by a rectangular demand.
Formalization Note The paper says "concave demand curve"; its proof invokes Theorem 1, which is about the inverse demand , so concavity is of in (footnote 6, p. 8, notes that concave gives concave demand). Existence of an optimum and are asserted so that the ratios are well defined; the bounds hold for every maximizer. Ratios are real divisions.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_LinearPriceRule_Concave_Model
namespace LinearPriceRule.Concave
theorem proposition_5 (M : Market) (hM : M.Standing)
(hconc : ConcaveOn ℝ (Set.Icc 0 M.Qmax) M.PA) :
(∃ Q, IsOptQty M Q) ∧ 0 < linProfit M ∧
∀ Q, IsOptQty M Q →
(1 ≤ profit M Q / linProfit M ∧ profit M Q / linProfit M ≤ 2) ∧
(1 ≤ M.PA Q / linPrice M ∧ M.PA Q / linPrice M ≤ 2) := by sorry
end LinearPriceRule.Concave
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.