Dropping one schema instance destroys uniqueness
ProvedTranscendenceTower.Relaxation.relaxed_not_definitionalLet be the assumption to be relaxed, and impose the transcendence schema everywhere except at . Then there are two distinct transcending contexts extending the same base and satisfying every remaining instance: one that keeps the old value of , and one that relaxes it.
Two consequences follow. First, the relaxed tower is not a definitional extension: the new vocabulary is no longer determined by the old, so the argument that stages are conservative because they are definitional does not apply to it. Second, the relaxed schema is nonetheless consistent, since the two witnesses are models of it.
Relaxation is therefore not incoherent, merely underdetermined. What it loses is exactly the property that made the original tower harmless: uniqueness of the extension. And the loss is immediate — dropping a single instance of the schema already suffices, so no weakened form of definitional extension survives partial relaxation.
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerRelaxation set_option autoImplicit false open TranscendenceTower
namespace TranscendenceTower.Relaxation
theorem relaxed_not_definitional (v : Atom 0 → Bool) (a : Lang 0) :
∃ N₁ N₂ : Atom 1 → Bool,
ExtendsBase v N₁ ∧ ExtendsBase v N₂ ∧ N₁ ≠ N₂ ∧
(∀ p : Lang 0, p ≠ a → Form.eval N₁ (schema p) = true) ∧
(∀ p : Lang 0, p ≠ a → Form.eval N₂ (schema p) = true) := by sorry
end TranscendenceTower.Relaxation