Proposition 6, proof of (ii), (25a)–(25d), p. 19 — the worst-case ramp is attained at one of four extreme scenarios
ProvedMultistageRUC.WitPolicy.ramp_worst_case_in_fourLet be the budget uncertainty set (3), and let maximize, respectively minimize, the total load of every period over ((19), (20)). Fix a generator , coefficients , and two consecutive periods , . For a trajectory write
Let with the scenarios (21)–(22). Then for every :
- there is with ;
- there is with .
So both the maximum and the minimum of over are attained in the four-element set . Which scenario is extremal depends on the signs of and (the four cases (25a)–(25d) of the paper). The maximum governs the ramping-up constraints (8e), the minimum the ramping-down constraints (8d).
Formalization Note. Lean periods are 0-based and are indices s, t with t = s + 1. The scenarios , are defined exactly by (21)–(22): has period from and period from . The page's assignment of the labels (25a) and (25d) to these scenarios is swapped; the statement, which quantifies over the whole four-element set, is unaffected.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_MultistageRUC_WitPolicy_Setting
namespace MultistageRUC.WitPolicy
theorem ramp_worst_case_in_four {Ng Nd T : ℕ}
(W : Fin Ng → Fin T → ℝ) (dbar dhat : Fin T → Fin Nd → ℝ) (Γ : ℝ)
(dmax dmin : Fin T → Fin Nd → ℝ)
(hmax : IsMaxLoad (MultistageRUC.Equiv.uncSet dbar dhat Γ) dmax)
(hmin : IsMinLoad (MultistageRUC.Equiv.uncSet dbar dhat Γ) dmin)
(i : Fin Ng) (s t : Fin T) (hst : t.val = s.val + 1) :
∀ d ∈ MultistageRUC.Equiv.uncSet dbar dhat Γ,
(∃ d' ∈ ({dmin, dmax, dminmax dmin dmax t, dmaxmin dmin dmax t} :
Set (Fin T → Fin Nd → ℝ)),
W i t * totalLoad d t - W i s * totalLoad d s ≤
W i t * totalLoad d' t - W i s * totalLoad d' s) ∧
(∃ d' ∈ ({dmin, dmax, dminmax dmin dmax t, dmaxmin dmin dmax t} :
Set (Fin T → Fin Nd → ℝ)),
W i t * totalLoad d' t - W i s * totalLoad d' s ≤
W i t * totalLoad d t - W i s * totalLoad d s) := by sorry
end MultistageRUC.WitPolicy
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.