Kunen inconsistency in (open goal)
OpenKunenZF.kunen_inconsistency_zfThis is the central open problem: does set theory refute the existence of Reinhardt cardinals? It asserts that no structure models the Reinhardt theory , i.e. with a unary function symbol , Separation and Collection for all -formulas, the elementarity scheme for over pure -formulas, and the assertion that moves some set. Equivalently (by soundness and completeness), this first-order theory is inconsistent. A Reinhardt cardinal is the critical point of such a ; in nontriviality is equivalent to the existence of a critical point, so the statement is exactly that refutes Reinhardt cardinals.
The problem is open: Kunen refuted the statement under Choice (1971) and Suzuki refuted the parameter-definable case in (1999), but no proof or model in alone is known. A disproof of this goal would exhibit a model of the theory — a consistency result for choiceless large cardinals.
Formalization Note. Stated semantically and universe-polymorphically: for every type with a -structure, is not a model of the theory. This is equivalent to syntactic inconsistency by Gödel's completeness theorem.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_KunenZF_language import Definitions.Def_KunenZF_theory import Definitions.Def_CH_SetTheoryLanguage universe u open FirstOrder FirstOrder.Language
namespace KunenZF
theorem kunen_inconsistency_zf {M : Type u} [setLangJ.Structure M] :
¬ (M ⊨ reinhardtTheory) := by sorry
end KunenZFConfirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.