Nested finite coordinate cutoffs can retain a half-unit trace after reversing a projection
ProvedMasulloAudit.monotone_cutoff_reversed_projection_tracecounterexamplemasullo-auditoperator-theorytrace-class
On the orthogonal sum H=ℓ²(ℕ,ℂ)⊕ℓ²(ℕ,ℂ) there exist an orthogonal projection P and a bounded operator A with PA=0 and AP=A. Let M_n keep coordinates 0 through n in the first copy and 0 through n−1 in the second. These nested finite-rank orthogonal multiplication cutoffs tend strongly to the identity. Each M_n AP is nuclear and its trace equals 1/2.
This isolates a limit issue when passing from the order P A in Theorem 10.4.2.2 to A P in Theorem 10.4.2.8. Even zero trace-class P A and strong convergence of monotone self-adjoint cutoffs do not force the cutoff traces of A P to approach zero. The theorem tests the general operator inference. The particular adelic convolution and projection in Chapter 10 may satisfy additional estimates.
Preamble
import Definitions.Def_MasulloGRH_HilbertNuclear import Mathlib.Analysis.InnerProductSpace.ProdL2 open Filter Topology MasulloGRH
Formal statement
theorem MasulloAudit.monotone_cutoff_reversed_projection_trace :
let L := lp (fun _ : ℕ => ℂ) 2
let H := WithLp 2 (L × L)
∃ (P A : H →L[ℂ] H) (M : ℕ → H →L[ℂ] H), P.comp P=P ∧ IsSelfAdjoint P ∧
P.comp A=0 ∧ A.comp P=A ∧
(∀ n (u : H) j, (M n u).fst j = (if j<n+1 then u.fst j else 0) ∧
(M n u).snd j = (if j<n then u.snd j else 0)) ∧
(∀ u, Tendsto (fun n => M n u) atTop (𝓝 u)) ∧
(∀ n, IsNuclearOperator ((M n).comp (A.comp P)) ∧ operatorTrace ((M n).comp (A.comp P)) = 1/2) := by sorrySource
A. M. Masullo, The Music of the Primes, frozen 20 November 2026 draft, Theorem 10.4.2.2, eq. (10.4.2.9), pp. 459–461, and Theorem 10.4.2.8, eqs. (10.4.2.20) and (10.4.2.34), pp. 463–464. https://math216.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/the-music-of-the-primes.pdf