Appendix A.4, (A.25), p. 20 — without accelerability, an interior FC optimum has u′(R)λ − 1 > 0
ProvedAccelScal.FCMonopoly.fc_first_orderLet satisfy the standing assumptions, let , , , , and suppose the project is not accelerable but scalable: (so ) and (so ). Let be the set of maximizers of the FC value of (6) over .
Then every interior FC optimum, i.e. every with , satisfies
This is the consequence the paper draws from the FC first-order condition (A.25): the survival factor decreases in , so at an interior optimum the marginal perpetuity value must be strictly positive. Combined with the UC first-order condition and the concavity of , it places every FC optimum below the UC optimum.
Formalization Note. The FC value is the reduced problem (6), taken as the definition (its derivation from (3), Lemma 1, is not posed). " and " is encoded as and , which under (2) and are equivalent. The paper writes the exponent in this passage as ; it is Lemma 1's . is Mathlib's deriv of at .
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_AccelScal_FCMonopoly_Setting
namespace AccelScal.FCMonopoly
theorem fc_first_order (T : Tech) (hT : T.Standing) (r : ℝ) (hr : 0 < r) (μ σ X : ℝ)
(hσ : 0 < σ) (hγ : T.γ = 0) (hβ : 0 < T.β) :
∀ R ∈ RstarFC T r μ σ X, 1 < R → R < min T.Rbar X → 0 < deriv T.u R * T.lam R - 1 := by sorry
end AccelScal.FCMonopoly
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.